China must end persecution of Buddhists in Tibet, Enforced Disappearance Anniversary of The 11th Panchen Lama

By Tsering Passang

Today, on May 17, 2024, millions of Tibetan Buddhists worldwide are marking the 29th anniversary of China’s enforced disappearance of Gedhun Choekyi Nyima, His Serenity the 11th Panchen Lama of Tibet. Protests are being held in towns and cities across the globe, calling on the Chinese authorities to end the state persecution of Buddhists in China’s occupied Tibet.

Gedhun Choekyi Nyima, recognised as the reincarnation of the previous 10th Panchen Lama by His Holiness the Dalai Lama in accordance with Tibetan Buddhist tradition, vanished at the tender age of six in 1995, along with his family and a prominent Tibetan Buddhist master.

Born on April 25, 1989, Gedhun Choekyi Nyima’s public recognition by the Dalai Lama on May 14, 1995, was swiftly followed by his mysterious disappearance on May 17 of the same year. Alongside him vanished his parents and Venerable Jadrel Rinpoche, the Head of Tashi Lhunpo Monastery in Shigatse, Tibet, who was secretly in contact with the Dalai Lama regarding the search for the 11th Panchen Lama. Venerable Jadrel Rinpoche had been appointed by the Chinese Government to lead the Panchen Lama Search Committee.

China subsequently announced its own candidate, Gyaincain Norbu, as the 11th Panchen Lama, causing widespread skepticism and concern among Tibetans, who view Beijing’s involvement in their ancient religious tradition as politically motivated.

For Tibetan Buddhists, Gedhun Choekyi Nyima, recognised by the Dalai Lama, remains the legitimate reincarnation of the previous Panchen Lama. However, despite persistent requests for information, his whereabouts remain unknown to all except Chinese authorities. At the time of his disappearance, Gedhun Choekyi Nyima became the world’s youngest political prisoner.

The unresolved fate of the 10th Panchen Lama, who passed away under mysterious circumstances in 1989, also weighs heavily on the minds of Tibetans. Many suspect foul play by Chinese authorities, further deepening distrust and resentment.

The significance of the Panchen Lama in Tibetan society cannot be overstated. Successive Panchen Lamas have played vital roles in both the spiritual and temporal spheres of Tibetan life. Tashi Lhunpo Monastery, founded in 1447, serves as the traditional seat of the Panchen Lama, symbolising the historical and cultural importance of this lineage.

The 10th Panchen Lama made significant contributions to the Tibetan people’s welfare, particularly during the turbulent period following China’s occupation of Tibet. Despite initial collaboration with Chinese authorities, including roles in political committees, the 10th Panchen Lama later courageously criticised Communist Party policies in Tibet, documenting his findings in the famous 70,000-character petition.

This petition, a comprehensive indictment of Chinese policies in Tibet, remains a poignant reminder of the Panchen Lama’s unwavering commitment to his people’s well-being. Despite facing persecution, imprisonment, and public humiliation, he continued to advocate for Tibetan rights and cultural preservation.

The Chinese government’s interference in Tibetan religious affairs, exemplified by its manipulation of the Panchen Lama selection process, represents a blatant violation of religious freedom. By appointing its own candidate, Beijing seeks to control the Tibetan Buddhist hierarchy for political ends, undermining the spiritual authority of recognised leaders like the Dalai Lama and the legitimate Panchen Lama.

In light of these ongoing injustices, the international community, including nations like India, the United Kingdom and the United States, must continue to stand in solidarity with the Tibetan people. Upholding religious freedom and respecting Tibetan cultural heritage are essential principles that transcend geopolitical interests.

India, with its rich cultural heritage and historical ties to Tibet, can play a pivotal role in advocating for Tibetan rights and promoting dialogue between Tibetans and Chinese authorities. By supporting the Dalai Lama and the Tibetan community, India reaffirms its commitment to justice, peace, and the preservation of diverse religious traditions.

Tsering Passang, human rights activist, is the founder and chair of the Global for Tibet & Persecuted Minorities. He can be reached via www.Tsamtruk.com / @Tsamtruk (X / formerly twitter).

Venerable Ngakchen Rinpoche, Deputy Abbott and a senior Buddhist master at Tashi Lhunpo Monastery, south India, addressing at the Foreign Correspondents’ Club of South Asia in Delhi:

His Holiness the Dalai Lama’s Message for Buddha Purnima (Vesak) – 2024

(Source: DalaiLama.com)

FILE – In this April 5, 2017, file photo, Tibetan spiritual leader the Dalai Lama greets devotees at the Buddha Park in Bomdila, Arunachal Pradesh, India. More than 150 Tibetan religious leaders say their spiritual leader, the Dalai Lama, should have the sole authority to choose his successor. A resolution adopted by the leaders at a conference on Wednesday, Nov. 27, 2019, says the Tibetan people will not recognize a candidate chosen by the Chinese government for political ends. ( AP Photo/Tenzin Choejor, File)

Although it is more than 2500 years since the Buddha lived and taught in India, the essence of his teaching remains as relevant today as it was then. While modern science has developed a sophisticated understanding of the physical world, Buddhist science has devoted itself to developing a detailed, first-person understanding of many aspects of the mind and emotions, areas still relatively new to modern science. I believe that a synthesis of these two approaches has great potential to lead to discoveries that will enrich our physical, emotional and social well-being.

As a Tibetan Buddhist monk, I consider myself an heir to the Nalanda Tradition. The way Buddhism was taught and studied at Nalanda University represents the zenith of its development in India. If we are to be 21st century Buddhists, it is important that we engage in the study and analysis of the Buddha’s teachings, as so many did there, instead of simply relying on faith.

Buddha Purnima or Vesak commemorates Buddha Shakyamuni’s birth, enlightenment and passing away, and is considered the most sacred day in the Buddhist calendar. On this auspicious occasion, I offer fellow Buddhists everywhere my good wishes in leading meaningful lives filled with warm heartedness and compassion.

With my prayers and good wishes,

Dalai Lama

9 May 2024

Sombre 35th birthday celebration of Tibet’s missing spiritual leader: China must return the stolen Tibetan child – The 11th Panchen Lama

By Tsering Passang, founder and chair, Global Alliance for Tibet & Persecuted Minorities

“The enforced disappearance of the 11th Panchen Lama is a serious human rights issue that violates the basic dignity and rights of Tibetan people and the freedom to practice their religious and cultural identity.” – Ven. Kelkhang Rinpoche, General Secretary of the India-based Tashi Lhunpo Monastery

For the past 29 years, Tibetans and Buddhist followers have been waiting patiently for a glimpse of Gedhun Choekyi Nyima, The 11th Panchen Lama – Tibet’s second highest spiritual leader after His Holiness the Dalai Lama.

Born 25th April 1989, Gedhun Choekyi Nyima was recognised as the reincarnation of the 10th Panchen Lama by His Holiness the Dalai Lama as per the Tibetan Buddhist tradition, on 14th May 1995. Within days of his public recognition, on 17th May, the six-year old Gedhun Choekyi Nyima disappeared with his parents and Jadrel Rinpoche, Head of Tashi Lhunpo Monastery in Shigatse, who was in secretly in touch with the Dalai Lama in India regarding the 11th Panchen Lama’s search. Jadrel Rinpoche was appointed as the Head of the Panchen Lama Search Committee, entrusted by the Chinese Government.

Six months later, China announced its own 11th Panchen Lama, Gyaincain Norbu as the reincarnation of the previous 10th Panchen Lama.

For Tibetan Buddhists, the Dalai Lama’s recognised 11th Panchen Lama, Gedhun Choekyi Nyima is the true reincarnation of the previous 10th Panchen Lama. Despite repeated requests for access, the whereabouts of the Dalai Lama’s recognised Panchen Lama is not still known to anyone to this day, except to the Chinese authorities. At the time of his disappearance in 1995, Gedhun Choekyi Nyima became the world’s youngest political prisoner.

The mysterious death of the 10th Panchen Lama in 1989 is still a fresh memory to many of his followers. Tibetans suspect foul play by the Chinese authorities over their spiritual leader’s untimely death 35 years ago.

Significance of The Panchen Lama

Lobsang Trinley Lhündrub Chökyi Gyaltsen, The 10th Panchen Lama

The successive throne holders of the Panchen Lama lineage have contributed immensely to the temporal and spiritual traditions of Tibet. Tashi Lhunpo Monastery, founded in 1447 by the 1st Dalai Lama, is the traditional monastic seat of the Panchen Lama. It is a historically and culturally important Buddhist monastery based in Shigatse, Tibet’s second-largest city.

The 10th Panchen Lama’s significant contribution to the cause of the Tibetan people both in temporal and spiritual traditions, especially at a time of critical danger of being wiped out by the Chinese Communist regime cannot be discounted easily.

Following the illegal invasion of Tibet by the People’s Republic of China, and with the subsequent escape of the Dalai Lama into exile in India, in March 1959, the Chinese government courted the 10th Panchen Lama and appointed him as Chairman of the Preparatory Committee for the establishments of the Tibet Autonomous Region (TAR). In 1960, Beijing named him Vice-Chairman of the National People’s Congress (NPC) of the People’s Republic of China (PRC) in order that he acts as the spokesperson for Chinese policy in Tibet.

Formally established in 1965, the Tibet Autonomous Region (TAR) became Beijing’s newly-designed political entity aimed at splitting the whole Tibetan Nation into several regions. Other traditional Tibetan regions including Amdo (north-east) and Kham (east) were incorporated into neighbouring Chinese provinces such as Qinghai, Gansu, Yunnan and Sichuan. For Tibetans, Tibet comprises Dotoe (Kham), Domed (Amdo) and Utsang (central) – the three Cholkhas.

The Panchen Lama’s 70,000-character petition

After official tours across various places in Tibet, the 10th Panchen Lama started documenting his findings, started in Shigatse and completed in Beijing. Along with his recommendations, the Panchen Lama submitted the findings to Chinese Premier Zhou Enlai in 1962 – widely known as the 70,000-character petition.

In his official report, the Panchen Lama denounced the draconian policies and actions of the Chinese Communist Party (CCP) in Tibet. He also criticised the Great Leap Forward and a multitude of “inept orders” on the part of the CCP which had caused chronic food shortages.

In Beijing, the Panchen Lama also urged Mao Tsetung to “put an end to the abuses committed against the Tibetan people, to increase their food rations, to provide adequate care for the elderly and the poor, and to respect religious liberty.” Mao listened to him but did nothing to address the matters raised.

According to British journalist Isabel Hilton, the 70,000-character petition remains the “most detailed and informed attack on China’s policies in Tibet that would ever be written.”

For several decades, the Panchen Lama’s petition remained hidden from all but the very highest levels of the Chinese leadership, until one copy surfaced in 1996. In January 1998, to coincide with the 60th anniversary of the birth of the late 10th Panchen Lama, an English translation by Tibet expert Prof. Robert Barnett entitled A Poisoned Arrow: The Secret Report of the 10th Panchen Lama, was published by the London-based Tibet Information Network (TIN), now a defunct news research agency on Tibet.

In 1964, the 10th Panchen Lama was publicly humiliated at Politburo meetings, dismissed from all posts of authority, declared ‘an enemy of the Tibetan people’, and later imprisoned. At the time he was 26 years old. The Tibetan spiritual leader’s situation worsened when the Cultural Revolution started. The Chinese dissident Wei Jingsheng, who was a former Red Guard, published in March 1979 a letter under his name but written by another anonymous author denouncing the conditions at Qincheng Prison, where the 10th Panchen Lama was in captivity. In October 1977 the Panchen Lama was released, but held under house arrest in Beijing until 1982. After his release, the Panchen Lama served as Vice Chairman of the National People’s Congress.

Tseten Wangchuk, a senior Tibetan journalist working for the Voice of America’s (VOA) Tibetan section in the United States, reported that during a 1980 meeting between the Secretary of the Communist Party Hu Yaobang and the Panchen Lama, the latter told Hu “how much he was moved by his reforms, and remarked that had the suggestions of the 70,000-character petition been put in place when they were proposed, the problems in Tibet would not have endured.

The 70,000-character petition was founded on the principle that the specific characteristics of Tibet should be taken into account. This premise was central to the policies of Deng Xiaoping in China during the 1980s and allowed the Panchen Lama to introduce numerous liberalisations into Tibet. However, in early 1992, the CCP removed the concession concerning the “specific characteristics” of Tibet, and current policy monitors religious practices and the monasteries, limits the instruction of Tibetan language, and has since suppressed some of the religious and cultural liberalisations implemented by Hu Yaobang and requested by the Panchen Lama.

In March 1999, during the annual commemoration of Tibetan National Uprising of Lhasa in 1959, the Dalai Lama declared that “the 70,000-character petition published in 1962 by the former Panchen Lama constitutes an eloquent historical document on the policies carried out by the Chinese in Tibet and on the draconian measures put in place there.”

In brief, pushing aside his own personal safety issues, and for the sake of the Tibetan people’s identity, spiritual practice and survival of the unique way of life, the 10th Panchen Lama struggled fearlessly and unrelentingly for their preservation and promotion. He rebuilt Tibet’s religious and cultural heritages and worked hard in the interests of Tibetans, for which he gained high prestige among the Tibetans. His efforts have spread far and wide from Tibet into the Himalayan regions, and through these into the wider world. The previous 10th Panchen Lama has dedicated his whole life to Tibet and Tibetan people.

Why is Communist China interfering in the religious affairs of the Tibetan people?

The 10th Panchen Lama and the 14th Dalai Lama in 1954. The two Tibetan spiritual leaders were 16 and 19 years old respectively.

The “Article 36” of the Constitution of the People’s Republic of China guarantees “Citizens of the People’s Republic of China enjoy freedom of religious belief. No state organ, public organization or individual may compel citizens to believe in, or not to believe in, any religion; nor may they discriminate against citizens who believe in, or do not believe in, any religion.”

In the “Note on the Memorandum of Genuine Autonomy for the Tibetan People”, a follow-up clarification note submitted by the Envoys of His Holiness the Dalai Lama to the Chinese Government after the eighth round of talks in 2008, it states, “The spiritual relationship between master and student and the giving of religious teachings, etc. are essential components of the Dharma practice. Restricting these is a violation of religious freedom. Similarly, the interference and direct involvement by the state and its institutions in matters of recognition of reincarnated lamas, as provided in the regulation on management of reincarnated lamas adopted by the State on July 18, 2007 is a grave violation of the freedom of religious belief enshrined in the Chinese Constitution.”

The Dalai Lama and Panchen Lama share a warm and friendly relationship and have previously served as mentors and apprentices. They hold the highest decision-making power on the issue of reincarnation, and each had participated in the process of recognising each other’s reincarnation. If one of them passes away, the other has undertaken the responsibility of searching for the reincarnated soul boy of the other and vice-versa.

In his memoir, “Surviving The Dragon: A Tibetan Lama’s Account of 40 Years Under Chinese Rule”, Arjia Rinpoche, former member of the 11th Panchen Lama Search Committee, wrote, “As for the people of Tibet, no matter how politics changed, for them the Dalai Lama and the Panchen Lama remained the sun and the moon. To this day they believe that the reincarnations of both must be mutually recognised to be valid.”

Arjia Rinpoche, Abbott of the renowned Kumbum Monastery in Amdo, north-east Tibet, who had come to the United States via Guatemala as a political exile, wrote in his memoir, “Tibetans clearly wanted the Fourteenth Dalai Lama to be the final arbiter of the identity of the true reincarnation of the Panchen Lama.”

The real intention of the Chinese Government’s appointment of Gyaincain Norbu as the 11th Panchen Lama as opposed to the Dalai Lama’s chosen candidate is crystal clear – a political matter.

After the Chinese government’s official announcement of its 11th Panchen Lama on 29th November 1995, Arjia Rinpoche, who was to become his personal tutor, recalled the remarks made by Ye Xiaowen, Director of the State Administration for Religious Affairs, “When the Dalai Lama announced the name of his chosen candidate, the government immediately sent out charter jets, usually reserved for members of the Politburo, to the birthplaces of the three final candidates in the Naqu district of Tibet. They put the boys and their families on the three jets and whisked them away into hiding.”

On their return to Beijing from Lhasa, in the chartered plane, dumbfounded Arjia Rinpoche recalled Ye Xiaowen stating, “When we made our selection we left nothing to chance. In the silk pouches of the ivory pieces we put a bit of cotton at the bottom of one of them, so it would be a little higher than the others and the right candidate would be chosen”. Gyaincain Norbu’s parents are CCP officials.

In 2019, Gyaincain Norbu was made Head of the China Buddhist Association. The Chinese government will use its chosen Panchen Lama to tour the world and is expected to speak on freedom of religion enjoyed by everyone in China.

During Ye Xiaowen’s directorship at the State Administration for Religions Affair, not only did we see persecutions of Buddhists, Christians, Muslims and Falun Gong followers but he was instrumental in appointing Gyancian Norbu as the 11th Panchen Lama.

Further under Ye’s watch, he declared “State Religious Affairs Bureau Order No. 5” that attempted to reduce the influence of the 14th Dalai Lama and other foreign groups on the reincarnations in Tibet.

Chinese government over the years has made concerted efforts to bring down the image of the Dalai Lama by labelling him as “separatist”. The CCP has also banned the photos of the Dalai Lama and possessing his photos is considered as an act of crime.

At the heart of all these things is the issue of reincarnation of the Dalai Lama. For years the Chinese government has been grooming its own Panchen Lama. It is most likely that he will play an instrumental role in deciding the reincarnation of the next Dalai Lama in China. This is expected to lead to two Dalai Lamas in the future if the current Dalai Lama decides to keep the tradition of reincarnation of the Dalai Lama continues.

The fact of the matter is that the issue of reincarnation of the Dalai Lama is not limited to China and the Dalai Lama but it now has larger geopolitical consideration with security implications in the Himalayan regions.

The US has shown its full support for Tibet on the reincarnation issue i.e. whatever the Tibetan people decide to choose. It has, in late 2020, passed the Tibet Policy and Support Act (TPSA) and it sends a strong message to China that the US stands steadfast with the Dalai Lama and the Central Tibetan Administration (aka Tibetan Government-in-exile) on the issue of Tibetan reincarnation.

Home to millions of Buddhists, especially Tibetan Buddhism, the great nation of India too can play a supporting role to His Holiness the Dalai Lama as well as to the Central Tibetan Administration towards the continuity of the Dalai Lama’s reincarnation system as per the Tibetan tradition.

Sign the Petition – Where is the Panchen Lama?

Secretary Chime Tseyang (1972 – 2024) – A Personal Tribute

I am very saddened to learn of the untimely death of Chime Tseyang-la earlier today in Delhi. Chime-la is one of the few Tibetan women in the senior leadership post, who was serving as the Secretary at the Department of Religion and Culture, Central Tibetan Administration (CTA) in Dharamsala. 

The leaderships and staff of the Central Tibetan Administration during the prayer ceremony to mourn the demise of Secretary Chime Tseyang. (Photo: Tibet.net)

According to the Circular released by the CTA Cabinet Office, Chime Tseyang-la died this morning at 6am at a hospital in Delhi, where she was receiving treatment. An official prayer service was held to mourn her death by the small Tibetan civil service and leadership in Dharamsala in the afternoon of her death. According to Tibet.net, “Cabinet Secretary Tsegyal Chukya Dranyi read a brief biography of the late Secretary and officiating Sikyong Tharlam Dolma Changra, the Kalon of Department of Education, conveyed her sadness at the painful news and asked everyone to offer prayers for the departed Secretary.”

From my professional dealing with Chime-la, especially when she was heading the Sponsorship and Scholarship Section at the Department of Education, CTA, I found her not only professional and soft spoken, but genuinely an open, friendly and good person. Furthermore, I observed her passion in making a difference to the Tibetan refugee community through her civil service profession. I met Chime-la on multiple occasions during my India trips, including in 2008, 2010, 2012 and 2014, when I was working for the Tibet Relief Fund.

My prayers for the deceased soul, thoughts and condolences with Chime-la’s family at this very difficult time. Om Mani Padme Hung. 

Tsering Passang, London (UK)

Brief bio of Secretary Chime Tseyang (Source: CTA)

Secretary Chime Tseyang was born to Pema Losel and Jodon in Chauntra Tibetan Settlement, Himachal Pradesh, on 1 August 1972 and did her primary and elementary schooling from CST Chauntra and CST Paonta, respectively. She completed her secondary and higher secondary education at CST Mussoorie and later pursued her Bachelor of Arts from GCG Government College for Girls in Chandigarh.

Following graduation, she worked at Dolma Ling Nunnery and Institute for over two and a half years before joining the Central Tibetan Administration in 2000 as Under Secretary at the Department of Education. She was promoted to Deputy Secretary on 19 November 2004 and to Joint Secretary on 13 October 2010 at the Education Department where she served almost 16 years in total. On 1 September 2016, Secretary Chime Tseyang was promoted to the post of Additional Secretary and was transferred to Department of Information and International Relations, where she was subsequently promoted to Secretary post on 17 August 2020. On 1 September 2021, she was appointed as the Secretary of the Department of Religion and Culture. The departed Secretary was survived by her husband, Tenzin Lungtok, the Justice Commissioner of the Tibetan Supreme Justice Commission, and their daughter.

Tibetan Interview with Radio Free Asia: Tsering Passang, Founder and Chair, Global Alliance for Tibet & Persecuted Minorities

In this candid interview with Tashi Wangchuk, Senior Editor at Radio Free Asia (Tibetan), Tsering Passang, who is the founder and chair of the Global Alliance for Tibet & Persecuted Minorities (GATPM), shares his viewpoints, strategies and analysis on China-Tibet Conflict. Passang also speaks on challenges posed by China’s ongoing Information War on Tibet, as well as cyber attacks and online harassments he personally experienced, whilst campaigning for the rights of the Tibetans and other persecuted communities under Communist China’s rule.

Passang says that the Global Alliance for Tibet & Persecuted Minorities was started off as an online platform in summer 2020 during COVID-19, when he initially hosted webinars on Tibet and Human Rights in China by inviting scholars, parliamentarians, and human rights and political activists to raise awareness.

Click the link below to listen to the interview!

Source: Radio Free Asia (Tibetan):

བོད་དང་འཛམ་གླིང་ནང་དཀའ་སྡུག་མྱོང་བའི་གྲངས་ཉུང་མི་རིགས།

བོད་དང་འཛམ་གླིང་ནང་དཀའ་སྡུག་མྱོང་བའི་གྲངས་ཉུང་མི་རིགས་ཀྱི་གོ་ལའི་སྣ་མཐུན་ཚོགས་པ་ཞིག་ཕྱི་ལོ་ ༢༠༢༠ ལོར་དབྱིན་ཡུལ་དུ་གསར་འཛུགས་ཀྱིས་འགན་འཛིན་ཚེ་རིང་པ་སངས་ལགས་ཀྱིས་བོད་ཀྱི་གནད་དོན་ཐད་འཐབ་རྩོད་ཀྱི་བརྒྱུད་ལམ་གསར་པ་ཞིག་བཙལ་འཚོལ་བྱུང་ཞིང་།  རྒྱ་ནག་ནང་ཏུ་ཏོག་དབྱིབས་ནད་ཡམས་ཀྱི་གནད་དོན་དང་རྒྱ་སྐྱེད་རིང་ལུགས་ཀྱི་སྲིད་བྱུས་ཤུགས་ཆེར་ལག་བསྟར་བྱེད་པའི་རྗེས་སུ་བོད་དང་མཉམ་སྦྲེལ་བྱེད་པའི་མཐུན་ཚོགས་ཀྱི་ལས་དོན་ལ་དམིགས་བཀར་དོ་སྣང་བྱེད་མཁན་ཆེ་རུ་ཕྱིན་པ་ཁོང་གིས་མྱོང་ཚོར་བྱུང་པ་གསུངས་ཀྱི་འདུག  ཐེངས་འདིའི་གནད་དོན་གླེང་མོལ་གྱི་ལས་རིམ་ནང་།  བོད་དོན་ལས་འགུལ་གྱི་འཐབ་རྩོད་བརྒྱུད་རིམ་ཁྲོད་རྒྱ་ནག་གི་སྡུག་སྦྱོང་འོག་དཀའ་སྡུག་མྱོང་བཞིན་པའི་མི་རིགས་གཞན་དང་མཉམ་ལས་བྱེད་པའི་དགེ་སྐྱོན་ཐད་ཨེ་ཤེ་ཡ་རང་དབང་རླུང་འཕྲིན་ཁང་གི་བོད་སྐད་སྡེ་ཚན་གྱི་འགན་འཛིན་གཞོན་པ་ལས་ཚབ་བཀྲ་ཤིས་དབང་ཕྱུག་ལགས་ཀྱིས་ཚེ་རིང་པ་སངས་ལགས་དང་ལྷན་གླེང་མོལ་ཞུས་པ་ཞིག་གསན་རོགས་གནང་།
གསར་འགོད་པ། བཀྲ་ཤིས་དབང་ཕྱུག
རྩོམ་སྒྲིག་པ། བཀྲ་ཤིས་དབང་ཕྱུག
དྲྭ་ཐོག་སྤེལ་མཁན། ཡེ་ཤེས་བཀྲ་ཤིས།

https://www.rfa.org/tibetan/world/global-alliance-for-tibet-persecuted-minorities-04062024101326.html

Tibet’s Intangible Cultural Heritage Featured at Woolwich Heritage Celebrations

By Tsering Passang

Commissioned by the Royal Borough of Greenwich (RGB), the Museum of London Archaeology (MOLA) delivered the two-year Woolwich Heritage Programme with the finale celebrations event held in Woolwich on 5th April. The day-long Woolwich Heritage celebrations included talks, heritage tours and Tibetan cultural dance performance.

Tibetan cultural performance at The Woolwich Library Centre / 5th April 2024 (Photo: Gyan Tamang)

Woolwich, a thriving English town located in southeast London, is the headquarters of the Royal Borough of Greenwich. The town’s location on the River Thames led to its status as an important naval, military and industrial area; a role that was maintained throughout the 16th to 20th centuries. Woolwich is one of 68 High Streets Heritage Action Zones across England, and one of only five in London, receiving a portion of the £95 million government-funding. Delivered by Historic England, the fund is aimed at unlocking the potential of high streets across England, fuelling economic, social and cultural recovery and breathing new life into town centres for future generations.

As part of the Royal Borough of Greenwich’s two-year Woolwich Heritage Programme (2022 – 2024), the Museum of London Archaeology (MOLA) also delivered four-short introductory training courses in Buildings Archaeology to Woolwich residents. MOLA’s partners, Our Hut designed and implemented a programme of events including exhibitions, family workshops, walking tours and school workshops focused on the architecture of Woolwich Town Centre. Furthermore, a film night was held at Tramshed, including a century of archive footage of Woolwich, as well as showcasing two contemporary films, ‘Woolwich Speaks’ by Crixus Productions and ‘Future Proof’, commissioned by Our Hut and made by students from Thomas Tallis School working with Foreign Body Productions. Our Hut’s amazing month-long exhibition was on display at The Woolwich Centre Library, from 8th March to 8th April.

Woolwich Heritage Exhibition at The Woolwich Centre Library run by http://www.OurHut.co.uk from 8th March – 8th April 2024 and can be viewed during standard library opening times. https://www.eventbrite.co.uk/cc/woolwich-heritage-action-zone-celebration-3098469
Woolwich Heritage Exhibition at The Woolwich Centre Library run by http://www.OurHut.co.uk from 8th March – 8th April 2024 and can be viewed during standard library opening times. https://www.eventbrite.co.uk/cc/woolwich-heritage-action-zone-celebration-3098469
Woolwich Heritage Exhibition at The Woolwich Centre Library run by http://www.OurHut.co.uk from 8th March – 8th April 2024 and can be viewed during standard library opening times. https://www.eventbrite.co.uk/cc/woolwich-heritage-action-zone-celebration-3098469
Cat Gibbs of the Museum of London Archaeology, speaking at the Tibetan Cultural Performance at The Woolwich Centre Library / 5th April 2024

The day-long Woolwich Heritage celebrations on 5th April included children’s activities, heritage tours, and talks at Woolwich Front Room and The Woolwich Centre Library. Woolwich HSHAZ Steering Committee member, Richard Buchannan, a retired electrical design Engineer and member of the District Antiquarian Society, gave a talk on ‘A Woolwich Experience’ in the morning.

Photo: Two sisters Choekyi and Chonyi / 5th April 2024 (Photo: Gyan Tamang)

In the afternoon, Tsering Passang, another Steering Committee member of the Woolwich HSHAZ, who is also the founder and chair of the Global Alliance for Tibet & Persecuted Minorities, spoke on Tibet’s connection with Woolwich dating back to the 1910s, as well as the small Tibetan community in the Royal Borough. Born in a refugee camp in Nepal, Passang came to England in 1996 on a scholarship programme, and later moved to Woolwich in 2007. 

Tsering Passang and Dr. Katrina Foxton / Woolwich Front Room / 5th April 2024 (Photo: Londonney)

A Gist of Tsering Passang’s Tibet Talk:

I am delighted to support the Royal Borough of Greenwich’s two-year Woolwich Heritage Programme, delivered by the Museum of London Archaeology (MOLA) and partners, bringing a great benefit to the local community, promoting and celebrating diversity, cultures and heritage in the borough. After being asked to join the Steering Committee of the Woolwich HSHAZ, whilst it was an honour for me to give back to the local community, I was initially wondering how best I can contribute to realise the noble objectives of the Woolwich Heritage Programme in the borough. To be honest, I had very little interest and understanding of the building heritage when I first joined the Steering Committee, however, this changed over time. Bringing people together through music and dance is something I continued to express, as someone who is a recent arrival to the area from a different cultural background. I am very glad that it was taken positively by Dr. Katrina Foxton, Engagement Project Officer for Museum of London Archaeology, and Rob Trimmer of the Royal Borough of Greenwich, recognising Tibet’s intangible cultural heritage, which is so important to the Tibetans living in this beautiful and historical borough. This is well reflected in my brief chat with Dr Foxton, [watch from 42:43] filmed by Londonney.

Intangible cultural heritage such as music and dance attract and bring people together, especially for the newer communities in the borough. Whilst enhancing the understanding of each other’s cultures, we can celebrate and embrace diversity, heritage and histories in the Royal Borough of Greenwich. Public spaces such as the Beresford Square in the heart of Woolwich should be used more often to showcase cultural performances by various communities living in the Royal Borough of Greenwich, which can contribute towards the long term objectives of the Woolwich High Street Heritage Action Zone project. 

Tibet’s connection with Woolwich: When Britain was willing to aid the Tibetans in the beginning of the 20th century, as part of modernising Tibet, the previous 13th Dalai Lama’s experiment with modern education resulted in the British welcoming four young Tibetan students from Lhasa, dubbed ‘Rugby Boys’, aged between 12 and 15, in April 1913. The two younger Tibetan students – Sonam Gonpa Gongkar and Rigzin Dorje Ringang received some of their training in Woolwich – at the Royal Military Academy and the Royal Arsenal during and after the First World War. 

After China’s occupation of Tibet, His Holiness the Dalai Lama escaped into exile in India, in March 1959; some 80,000 Tibetans followed him. In the early 1980s, a young Tibetan family moved to Woolwich. The following decades saw more Tibetans moving to the riverside town, and today about 200 Tibetans are living in Woolwich and neigbhouring towns. Over the past 15 years, the Greenwich Tibetan Association set up the Tashiling Tibetan School, which is being run within the borough’s premises at weekends, providing free Tibetan language and cultural education to the young Tibetan children. The Woolwich Centre Library has also become an important hub for Tibetan children’s learning activities in recent years. These language and cultural activities are voluntarily run by members of the local Tibetan community.

Furthermore, the Royal Borough of Greenwich raised the Tibet Flag for the first time in the Woolwich Town Hall in September 2015, to accord a warm welcome reception to His Holiness the Dalai Lama, when the Tibetan spiritual leader was visiting The O2 Centre in North Greenwich to give public talks and Buddhist teachings to over 10,000 people that year. Since 2020, successive elected Mayors of the Royal Borough of Greenwich have been raising the Tibet Flag at the Town Hall in the month of March to show support and solidarity with the people of Tibet, particularly those Tibetans living within the borough. This noble gesture shown by the Royal Borough of Greenwich sends out a strong message to China’s brutal regime that Britain stands firm on freedom, justice, democracy and human rights of the Tibetan people.

Acknowledgement: I would like to thank Dr. Katrina Foxton, Engagement Project Officer at Museum of London Archaeology, and Mr. Rob Timmer of the Directorate of Regeneration, Enterprise & Skills, Royal Borough of Greenwich, amongst others, for giving me an opportunity to serve on the Steering Committee of the Woolwich High Street Heritage Action Zone (HSHAZ) over the past two years. This opportunity has presented me with a new learning experience whilst building some new alliances for Tibet.

*Tsering Passang, Founder and Chair of the Global Alliance for Tibet & Persecuted Community, served on the Steering Committee of the Woolwich High Street Heritage Action Zone (HSHAZ) Project, from April 2022 to April 2024, on recommendation from the Royal Borough of Greenwich to Museum of London Archaeology (MOLA).

Youdon Lhamo, President of Greenwich Tibetan Association (GTA), played a vital role in facilitating the Tibetan cultural performance at The Woolwich Centre Library / 5th April 2024
Tibetan performers at The Woolwich Centre Library / 5th April 2024

Media Coverage

Histories of Immigration – The Tibetan Refugee Community in Woolwich, Royal Borough of Greenwich

Tsering Passang: I support the Woolwich Heritage project.

On 5th April, I will be speaking at the Woolwich Front Room in Woolwich, where McDonald’s opened its first restaurant in the UK, in October 1974. Organised by the Museum of London Archaeology (MOLA), this event is part of the Woolwich Heritage Action Zone Celebration collection, supported by the Royal Borough of Greenwich

Date: Fri, 5 Apr 2024 14:00 – 14:45 BST

Venue: Woolwich Front Room, 105 Powis Street, Woolwich, London SE18 6JB. For more about the talk, please visit EventBrite page.

Please visit this link for the full celebration events: https://www.eventbrite.co.uk/cc/woolwich-heritage-action-zone-celebration-3098469

https://www.mola.org.uk/get-involved/events/woolwich-heritage-celebration

Woolwich, a thriving English town located in southeast London, is the headquarters of the Royal Borough of Greenwich. It has excellent transport links and the London City Airport is only five minutes by Docklands Light Railway (DLR) service. The town’s location on the River Thames led to its status as an important naval, military and industrial area; a role that was maintained throughout the 16th to 20th centuries. 

Woolwich is one of 68 High Streets Heritage Action Zones across England, and one of only five in London, that will be given a new lease of life thanks to a £95 million government-funded programme. The fund is being delivered by Historic England and will unlock the potential of high streets across England, fuelling economic, social and cultural recovery and breathe new life into town centres for future generations.

I joined the Steering Committee of the Woolwich High Street Heritage Action Zone (HSHAZ) in April 2022, on recommendation from the Royal Borough of Greenwich to the MOLA team. I first moved to Woolwich in 2007 and have remained in close association with the Royal Borough to this day. I am delighted to support this important Woolwich Heritage project undertaken by the MOLA and partners, bringing a great benefit to the local community, promoting and celebrating diversity, cultures and heritage in the Royal Borough.

Woolwich Heritage Exhibition at The Woolwich Centre Library run by http://www.OurHut.co.uk from 8th March – 8th April 2024 and can be viewed during standard library opening times. https://www.eventbrite.co.uk/cc/woolwich-heritage-action-zone-celebration-3098469
Woolwich Heritage Exhibition at The Woolwich Centre Library run by http://www.OurHut.co.uk from 8th March – 8th April 2024 and can be viewed during standard library opening times. https://www.eventbrite.co.uk/cc/woolwich-heritage-action-zone-celebration-3098469
Woolwich Heritage Exhibition at The Woolwich Centre Library run by http://www.OurHut.co.uk from 8th March – 8th April 2024 and can be viewed during standard library opening times. https://www.eventbrite.co.uk/cc/woolwich-heritage-action-zone-celebration-3098469

As well as talking about the Tibetans residing in the Royal Borough of Greenwich, Greenwich Tibetan Association “GTA” and their ongoing activities, I will also be recollecting memories of the past, including the two young Tibetan students who received some of their training in Woolwich in the 1910s in the historic buildings! When Britain was willing to aid the Tibetans in beginning of the 20th century, as part of modernising Tibet, the previous 13th Dalai Lama’s experiment with modern education resulted in the British welcoming four young Tibetan students from Lhasa, dubbed ‘Rugby Boys’, aged between 12 and 15, in April 1913. Two of the young boys received some of their training in Woolwich – at the Royal Military Academy and the Royal Arsenal during and after the First World War.

About sixty years later, in 1981-82, a young Tibetan family moved to Woolwich. The following decades saw more Tibetans moving to the riverside town, and today about 200 Tibetans are living in Woolwich and neigbhouring towns. Over the past decade or so, the Greenwich Tibetan Association set up the Tashiling Tibetan School, which is being run within the borough’s premises at weekends, providing free Tibetan language and cultural education to the young Tibetan children. The Woolwich Centre Library has become an important hub for Tibetan children’s learning activities in recent years. These language and cultural activities are voluntarily run by members of the local Tibetan community.

Elected Councillors proudly share that the Royal Borough of Greenwich hosts the largest group of Tibetans in the whole of the UK. Local MPs and the Councillors are equally sympathetic and supportive of the Tibetan people and their just cause; the Tibet Flag is hoisted at the Town Hall every year in March, in show of support and solidarity with them. The Tibet Flag was first raised in the Town Hall in September 2015 to accord a warm welcome reception to His Holiness the Dalai Lama, when the Tibetan spiritual leader gave public talks and Buddhist teachings at The O2 Centre to over 10,000 people in September that year.

Group Photo: Cllr. Averil Lekau (Deputy Leader, Royal Borough of Greenwich), Youdon Lhamo (GTA President), Cllr.  Dr. Dominic Mbang (Mayor, Royal Borough of Greenwich), Cllr. David Gardner (former Deputy Leader, Royal Borough of Greenwich) and Tsering Passang (Steering Committee member, Woolwich High Street Heritage Action Zone) during “Losar” – Tibetan New Year Celebrations at Asian Community Centre, 9th February 2024, organised by Greenwich Tibetan Association (GTA).

The riverside town has also attracted small businesses run by Tibetan entrepreneurs, including Kailash Momo Restaurant, the first Tibetan restaurant in the Royal Borough, which was opened in 2011. Several other eateries – Rewa Sushi and Momo Bar and Wow Sushi London were opened in the past few years. Iro Sushi Woolwich is the latest venture by two young Tibetans living in the Royal Borough.

Photo: Interior at Kailash Momo Restaurant, Woolwich

Tibetan Dance Performance

The Greenwich Tibetan Association will present Tibetan Dance Performance and Fashion Walk in traditional Tibetan costumes from 15:30 until 16:30 to round up the celebrations in The Woolwich Centre Library, 35 Wellington Street, London SE18 6HQ. All welcome to these free events!

Please visit these links for the full celebration events: https://www.eventbrite.co.uk/cc/woolwich-heritage-action-zone-celebration-3098469

https://www.mola.org.uk/get-involved/events/woolwich-heritage-celebration

Photo: Losar – Tibetan New Year celebrations at Asian Community Centre, 9th February 2024, organised by Greenwich Tibetan Association (GTA)
Photo: First UK Lhakar Gorshey (Tibetan Circle Dance) at Beresford Square, Woolwich on 21st November 2021. Joined by Cllr. David Gardner – https://tsamtruk.wordpress.com/2021/11/22/lhakar-uk-kicked-off-with-gorshey-tibetan-circle-dance-in-london-woolwich/
Photo: First UK Lhakar Gorshey (Tibetan Circle Dance) at Beresford Square, Woolwich on 21st November 2021. Joined by Cllr. David Gardner – https://tsamtruk.wordpress.com/2021/11/22/lhakar-uk-kicked-off-with-gorshey-tibetan-circle-dance-in-london-woolwich/

Useful Links:

Royal Borough of Greenwich

Museum of London Archaeology (MOLA)

Our Hut

Lhakar UK kicked-off with “Gorshey: Tibetan Circle Dance” in London-Woolwich

Why Tibet Matters: Significance of Tibet in Geopolitics discussed ahead of the 65th anniversary of the Tibetan National Uprising of 1959

English Town Hall to raise Tibet Flag in show of support and solidarity with the Tibetan people

The China-Tibet Conflict: Need for Historic Decisions

By Tsering Passang* / First published by Phayul on 9th October 2008

Both Beijing and Dharamsala frequently reiterate their ‘sincerity’ in the search for a resolution of the China-Tibet conflict. As an ordinary Tibetan I welcome any positive moves from either side.

Since the Chinese and Tibetan officials in Beijing, Lhasa and Dharamsala all claim to work in the interests of all ordinary Tibetans, both those residing inside Tibet and in exile, it should be possible for leaders of both parties to show real courage and make bold political decisions to resolve the Tibet problem once and for all.

Following the Dalai Lama’s recent official delegation, led by Kasur Lodi Gyari, to meet with Du Qinglin, Head of the United Front Work Department of the Communist Party of China (CPC) Central Committee, the Special Envoy for the Tibetan Leader described the latest round of dialogue as “one of the most difficult sessions.” In his press statement he went on and said, “In the course of our discussions we were compelled to candidly convey to our counterparts that in the absence of serious and sincere commitment on their part, the continuation of the present dialogue would serve no purpose.”

Recent international pressure on the authorities in Beijing had given some hope to Tibetans around the world that the latest round of dialogue might have a more positive outcome. The press statement by the Dalai Lama’s Special Envoy was an unusually forthright admission of the delegation’s failure and reflected the growing frustration in Dharamsala at the lack of sincerity in Beijing. Chinese officials have in the past been quick to accuse the Tibetan side of a lack of “sincerity” but the entire world can now see that the truth is the opposite: it is China which lacks sincerity and shows no desire for settlement. It should also be noted that over the years the Tibetan side has made many compromises and concessions from its original demand for independence but this is not enough. China wants complete capitulation.

As a concerned Tibetan I would like to present my thoughts to both parties for some possible “tangible” results. The leadership in Dharamsala now has to consider seriously the strong message from the Chinese side and the Tibetan Government-in-Exile (TGiE) must be bold in its decision-making.

Proposed agenda for meaningful results

If we are ever to have tangible results from meetings to resolve the China-Tibet conflict then the next agenda should – in my view – include the following points:

1. Dharamsala should note China’s real concern that the Tibetan issue remain as an “internal affair” of the PRC and should not internationalise it. This could mean His Holiness the Dalai Lama stops travelling overseas whilst serving as the political leader of the Tibetan people as such trips attract international media attention. Beijing sees this as overtly political even though Dharamsala may view this differently.

2. The Tibet Support Groups (TSG) Desk based at the TGiE’s Department of Information and International Relations (DIIR) which maintains close links with Tibet Support Groups around the world should be closed down. His Holiness and the TGiE should detach themselves from political links with all International Tibet Support Groups and from World Parliamentarians Groups for Tibet whilst Dharamsala engages in direct dialogue with the Central Leadership in Beijing.

3. The political interest and quasi-diplomatic roles, which are currently being carried out by the various Offices of Tibet around the world, should have its “mission review” thoroughly whilst Dharamsala engages in direct dialogue with Beijing. Such Offices are currently in Australia, Belgium, India, Japan, Russia, South Africa, Switzerland, U.K. and U.S.A.

Whilst the above steps are being taken, the Central Leadership in Beijing, in agreement with His Holiness the Dalai Lama and the TGiE, should work to establish:

1. An Intermediary Agency in Beijing, representing His Holiness the Dalai Lama and the TGiE.

2. An Intermediary Agency in Dharamsala, representing the Central Government of the People’s Republic of China (PRC).

3. Joint-Intermediary Agencies in Lhasa, representing both the PRC, His Holiness the Dalai Lama and the TGiE.

4. Through the Intermediary Agencies, both sides should make joint contributions towards aid, education, social and economic development both inside Tibet and amongst Tibetans living in the Diaspora.

5. Formal exchange schemes between Dharamsala and Beijing should be developed, including conferences on research and scholastic work amongst the Tibetan Buddhist and Bon religious masters, scholars of history and medical practitioners. Both sides should give serious thought towards facilitating the learning and sharing of the valuable and masterly works of the rich cultural history of Tibet.

6. Formal and informal relationships between ordinary Tibetans from inside and outside Tibet need to be fostered and should include cultural exchanges such as exhibitions, the visits of traditional and modern performing artists, and traditional and modern artists, including thangka painters.

Through the above steps some “tangible” and practical progress may be achieved in areas in which both Chinese and Tibetans have concerns. Political solutions may take longer. Such steps would also lead to the building of confidence and trust whilst fully engaging in creating a genuine and conducive environment for progress which Dharamsala has been calling for some time. Proper negotiations need to be based on “Ume Lam” (Middle-Way approach), which means not splitting Tibet (all the three traditional provinces i.e. Amdo, Kham and U-Tsang must be under one political entity) from the Great Motherland, the People’s Republic of China.

Whilst the political negotiations continue, leaders on both sides should give sincere thoughts to establishing the Intermediary Agencies to serve all Tibetans. If the above or similar suggestions are not agreeable to both sides then I seriously wonder whether there is any point in Dharamsala or Beijing “talking the talks” on the China-Tibet conflict.

Convincing the Chinese authorities while not alienating Tibetans and Tibet supporters

Merely voicing occasional appeals and sending out circulars urging Tibetans and Tibet support groups not to engage in public protests during the visit overseas of Chinese dignitaries, or slamming the recent activities of the Tibetan Youth Congress has failed to convince officials in Beijing. Moreover it sends mixed messages to Tibetans and their supporters throughout the world which can alienate those who are most actively committed to and participating in the freedom struggle for Tibet. Instead, show concrete actions and not just written circulars or appeals.

Time for a New Direction and Making Hard Decisions

In the event of a stalemate and failure to progress then I think Dharamsala has to remodel its existing political structures and perhaps adopt a new direction, whereby people can freely share their strongly-held views. This means that they should not be required to accept uncritically every statement by His Holiness. Such passivity adversely hinders the democratisation of Tibetan society by rendering it politically immature. People who genuinely hold alternative views from those of the Dalai Lama should not be slammed or denounced as unpatriotic. Tibetans need to grow up politically. We need to revise the “Charter” and separate Chos-Sid, religion and politics.

Tibetans cannot forever live sustained by ‘hope’ alone. As we approach fifty years in exile we have to make the most difficult decision, not only for the present generation of Tibetans but for future generations. Even so, we may not find a lasting political solution to the issue of Tibet for another fifty years.

During a Tibetan gathering in London in 2005, when a delegation of Tibetan Parliamentarians from Dharamsala was visiting the UK, I called for a policy review on ‘Ume Lam’ (Middle-Way approach), as adopted by the Tibetan Parliament-in-Exile towards a resolution of the China-Tibet conflict. Once again, I wish to reiterate my previous call as there is no sign of progress between Dharamsala and Beijing.

Complete retirement for the Dalai Lama

Whilst presently enjoying “semi-retirement”, His Holiness recently declared that he is much looking forward to “complete retirement” from the Tibetan political scene. We should seriously note this, while celebrating his massive achievements in many walks of life. The achievement that eludes him is a political solution to the China-Tibet conflict. His Holiness has led the Tibetan nation since the age of 16 and the failure in this area cannot be put down to any lack of effort or goodwill. But His Holiness deserves a rest and it is time for other leaders to emerge and put forward alternative proposals.

Tibetan people’s interest comes first

In short, I urge the Tibetan and Chinese leaders in Lhasa, Beijing and Dharamsala to put the interests of Tibet’s people first in keeping with their claims to ‘serve’ our interests and welfare. If you have courage, show it now. Let there be no more lingering.

*The writer was an independent candidate for Europe seats in the 2005 General Election for the 14th Session of the Tibetan Parliament-in-Exile, graduated from a British University in Information Technology. Tsering served on the Council of Tibetan Community in Britain as its Culture Secretary from 2002 to 2006. He worked for London-based Tibet Foundation from 2001 to 2007, which supports Tibetans inside Tibet, India and Nepal. Currently, Tsering is working for Tibet Relief Fund (UK).

Article 23: Joint Statement by 145 organisations worldwide in condemnation of Hong Kong and China’s officials for undermining the rule of law in Hong Kong

Led by Hong Kong Democracy Council, an important joint statement was released on 22nd March, signed by 145 Hong Kong community groups, advocacy organisations, and civil society partners worldwide, to oppose Article 23, which is set to be enforced in Hong Kong on Saturday, 23rd March 2024 following an expedited passage. The Global Alliance for Tibet & Persecuted Minorities are proud to join Hong Kong Democracy Council and its coalition in the condemnation of Hong Kong and China’s officials, who are responsible for undermining the rule of law in Hong Kong.

Joint Statement to Oppose Article 23

We, the undersigned organizations, firmly oppose the passage of the Safeguarding National Security Bill, commonly referred to as “Article 23,” set to be enforced in Hong Kong this Saturday, March 23. We condemn the Hong Kong S.A.R. government’s plan to dismantle Hong Kong’s autonomy under the guise of “national security,” which further exacerbates the existing crackdown on human rights. 

Article 23’s vague and broad definitions of crimes adversely impact not only individuals facing political arrests and prosecutions, but also everyone else in Hong Kong. The law opens the door to further arbitrary arrests and detentions while escalating censorship, creating a global chilling effect. 

Article 23 is designed to impact an unprecedentedly wide range of people. The law, for example, defines the crime of “espionage” as applicable to those who, “with intent to endanger national security,” obtain, collect, or possess information that is “directly or indirectly useful to an external force” (clause 41). It also broadly criminalizes acts with “seditious intention,” which includes an intention to bring anyone in Hong Kong “into hatred, contempt or disaffection” against the Chinese and Hong Kong governments, institutions or constitutional order. With such low thresholds for prosecutions, Article 23 could provide a pretext for even more politically-motivated prosecutions and convictions. 

Article 23 exacerbates the persecution of political prisoners and compounds the existing human-rights violations under the National Security Law (N.S.L.). The new legislation reinforces a separate judicial process for political cases, which involves appointed national security police officers in addition to handpicked prosecutors and judges, and deprives suspects of important procedural protections that were once available under Hong Kong’s legal system. Political prisoners charged under the N.S.L. have already been routinely denied bail, subjected to months of pre-trial detention, and deprived of the right to a jury trial. The new law further undermines these procedural rights by allowing the police to not only extend the period of detention without charge from the current 48 hours to a further 14 days, but also limit suspects’ access to counsel. 

In addition to those facing political persecution, international businesses and Hong Kongers not directly involved in politics will also feel the impact of Article 23, as the law intensifies existing censorship. Following the N.S.L., the Hong Kong government forced major media outlets, such as Stand News and Apple Daily, to shut down. With the passage of Article 23, investigative journalism and reporting on “sensitive” political issues – given the broad definitions of “state secrets” and “sedition” – become even riskier. Article 23’s chilling effect on the freedom of expression extends to the Hong Kong diaspora globally, as the new law applies to Hong Kong residents anywhere in the world. The law’s extraterritorial implications will undoubtedly set the stage for heightened transnational repression. 

The S.A.R. government expedited the passage of Article 23 despite mounting international pressure to uphold human rights. The U.N. Human Rights Committee issued a list of recommendations in 2022, urging the S.A.R. government to prioritize human rights. During the Universal Periodic Review on China in January this year, eight U.N. member states also called on the People’s Republic of China to repeal or review the N.S.L. Despite these clear and urgent appeals, the S.A.R. government opted to expedite the passage of Article 23 – clearing all legislative hurdles within 50 days of the initial public consultation. 

We call on governments around the world and the international community to: 

  1. Impose sanctions on Hong Kong and Chinese officials responsible for undermining the rule of law in Hong Kong, particularly those involved in the passage of the two pieces of “national security” legislation; 
  2. Review the status of the Hong Kong Economic and Trade Offices globally, with an eye towards shuttering their operations; 
  3. Offer asylum and other humanitarian pathways and provide temporary travel documents to Hong Kong human-rights defenders, especially those who have been labeled by S.A.R. authorities as “absconders” and are likely to face passport cancellation in the near future. 

Signatories: 

1. 29 Principles 

2. AfricaHongKongFrance (AHKF) 

3. Arizona for Hong Kong 

4. ARTICLE 19 

5. Asian Lawyers Network (ALN) 

6. Assembly of Citizens’ Representatives, Hong Kong 

7. Association of Cosmopolitan Culture Action Taichung 

8. Association of Hong Kongers in Western Australia 

9. Athenai Institue 10. Aus-Hong Kong Connex Inc 

11. Australia Capital Hong Kong Association 

12. Australia Hong Kong Link 

13. Australia Tibet Council 

14. Australian and New Zealand Alliance for Victims of the Chinese Communist Regime

15. Bay Area Friends of Tibet 

16. Befria Hongkong (Sweden) 

17. Birmingham HongKongers 

18. Blossom Community HK CIC 

19. Bonham Tree Aid CIC 

20. Bristol Hongkongers 

21. Britons in Hong Kong 

22. Campaign For Uyghurs 

23. Canada-Hong Kong Link 

24. Center For Uyghur Studies 

25. Chicago Solidarity with Hong Kong (CSHK) 

26. Chinese Human Rights Defenders (CHRD) 

27. Coalition of Students Resisting China 

28. Committee For Freedom in Hong Kong Foundation 

29. Committee to Protect Journalists 

30. Czechs Support Tibet 

31. Democracy for Hong Kong (D4HK) 

32. Dialogue China 

33. European Belarus Foundation 

34. European Values Center for Security Policy 

35. Fight for Freedom. Stand with Hong Kong. 

36. Finnish Hongkongers 

37. Flow HK 

38. Formosan Association for Human Rights 

39. Frankfurt Stands With Hong Kong 

40. Free Tibet 

41. Free Uyghur Now 

42. Freedom House 

43. Freiheit für Hongkong e.V. (FfHK) 

44. Friends of Hong Kong (Calgary) 

45. Fundacíon Para la Libertad de Nicaragua 

46. Germany Stands with Hong Kong 

47. Global Alliance for Tibet & Persecuted Minorities 

48. Grupo de Apoio ao Tibete – Portugal 

49. HKersUnited 

50. Hong Kong Aid 

51. Hong Kong Affairs Association of Berkeley 

52. Hong Kong Committee in Norway 

53. Hong Kong Democracy Council 

54. Hongkonger Community Center (HKCC Brisbane) 

55. Hongkonger in Deutschland e.V. 

56. Hongkongers in Britain (HKB) 

57. HongKongers in Leeds 

58. Hong Kongers in San Diego 

59. Hong Kongers in San Francisco Bay Area 

60. Hong Kong Forum, Los Angeles 

61. Hong Kong International Alliance Brisbane (HKIA Brisbane) 

62. Hong Kong Media Overseas (HKMO) 

63. Hong Kong Outlanders in Taiwan 

64. Hong Kong Scots 

65. Hong Kong Social Action Movements in Boston 

66. Hong Kong Student Advocacy Group – NYU 

67. Hong Kong Watch 

68. Human Rights in China 

69. Human Rights Network for Tibet and Taiwan (HRNTT) 

70. Humanitarian China 

71. Humanosh USA 

72. India Tibet Friendship Society NAGPUR 

73. Internationale Gesellschaft für Menschenrechte (IGFM) 

74. International Tibet Network 

75. Khmer Movement for Democracy 

76. KONGcentric 

77. Lady Liberty Hong Kong (LLHK) 

78. Lamp of Liberty 

79. Le Comité pour la Liberté à Hong-Kong 80. Liberté au Tibet (France) 

81. Lion Rock Café (New York) 

82. Manchester Stands With Hong Kong 

83. McMaster Stands With Hong Kong 

84. New School for Democracy (NSD Taiwan) 

85. New Yorkers Supporting Hong Kong (NY4HK) 

86. North America Taiwanese Professors’ Association (NATPA) 

87. Northern California Hong Kong Club 

88. North East Hongkongers Club – U.K. 

89. Norwegian Tibet Committee 90. Nottingham Stands With Hong Kong 

91. NYC852HKER 

92. Ontario Hong Kong Youth Action 

93. PMGI [Peace Media & Good Governance Institute] 

94. Power to Hongkongers 95. Reading UK Stands with HK 

96. Reporters Without Borders (RSF) 

97. Santa Barbara Friends of Tibet 

98. Scottish Hongkongers 

99. SEArious For HKG (Seattle) 

100. South Sudan Democratic Alliance (SSDA) 

101. Southampton Hongkongers 

102. Stand with HK@JPN 

103. Students for a Free Tibet International 

104. Students for a Free Tibet – Boston 

105. Students for a Free Tibet- India

106. Students for a Free Tibet – Japan 

107. Students for a Free Tibet – Middletown High School 

108. Students for a Free Tibet – Minnesota 

109. Students for a Free Tibet – New York/New Jersey 

110. Students for a Free Tibet -Toronto 

111. Students for Hong Kong 

112. Sutton Hong Kong Culture & Art Society 

113. Swedish Tibet Committee 

114. Swiss Tibetan Friendship Association 

115. Taiwan Association for Human Rights 

116. Taiwan East Turkestan Association (TETA) 

117. Taiwan Forever Association 

118. Taiwan Hong Kong Association 

119. Taiwan Labour Front 

20. Taiwan Youth Association for Transitional Justice and Kiōng-Seng 

121. Taiwanese Association In Japan 

122. Texans Supporting Hong Kong (TX4HK) 

123. Tibet Initiative Deutschland e.V. 

124. Tibet Justice Center 

125. Tibet Solidarity 

126. Tibet Support Group Ireland 

127. Tibet Support Committee, Denmark 

128. Tibetan Youth Association in Europe (TYAE) 

129. Uniting HongKongers (Australia) 

130. Unrepresented Nations and Peoples Organisation (UNPO) 

131. US Hongkongers Club 

132. Uyghur Academy International 

133. Uyghur American Association 

134. Uyghur Center for Human Rights and Democracy 

135. Uyghur Human Rights Project 

136. Vancouver Activists of Hong Kong (VAHK) 

137. Vancouver Hong Kong Forum Society 

138. Vancouver Society in Support of Democratic Movement (VSSDM) 

139. Victoria Hongkongers Association (Australia) 

140. Washingtonians Supporting Hong Kong (DC4HK) 

141. We The Hongkongers 

142. Winnipeg Hong Kong Concern 

143. World Federation of Taiwanese Associations 

144. World Liberty Congress 

145. World Uyghur Congress

USEFUL LINKS

Link to the original Joint Statement published on Hong Kong Democracy Council’s website.

Hong Kong Democracy Council

Article 23

China’s brutal crackdown on the 2000 Tibetan protesters in Dege must be condemned. Will you ask your MP to sign EDM no.530 in support of Tibetans in China’s occupied Tibet?

Chris Law MP / Photo: Wikipedia

Chris Law MP, Co-Chair of The All-Party Parliamentary Group (APPG) on Tibet, who is also the Scottish National Party (SNP) Spokesperson for International Development and Climate Justice, tabled an Early Day Motion (EDM) on the plight of peaceful Tibetan protesters in Dege County, Tibet on 19th March.

Treatment of Tibetan protesters in Dege County, Tibet

EDM (Early Day Motion)530: tabled on 19 March 2024 by Chris Law MP

This EDM no.530 can be accessed at https://edm.parliament.uk/early-day-motion/62026.

Tsering Passang, Founder and Chair, of the Global Alliance for Tibet & Persecuted Minorities, said: “Thank you Chris Law MP for tabling this timely Early Day Motion in the UK Parliament by drawing attention to the current plight of the 2000 Tibetans, who are being brutally crackdown by the Chinese authorities in their hometown of Dege for exercising their free speech. We hope the UK Parliament and Government as well as the Chinese authorities pay heed to Chris Law and his colleagues’ calls for positive actions for the affected Tibetans in Dege. China’s authorities must release the Tibetans immediately.”

Last month, on 15th February, Washington DC-based Radio Free Asia reported that at least 300 Tibetans gathered outside Dege County Town Hall to protest the building of the Gangtuo dam, which is part of a massive 13-tier hydropower complex on the Drichu River with a total planned capacity 13,920 megawatts. The dam project is on the Drichu River, called Jinsha in Chinese, which is located on the upper reaches of the Yangtze, one of China’s most important waterways. 

Tibetans in Dege county in southwestern China’s Sichuan province protest the Chinese government’s construction of a hydropower dam on the Drichu River, Feb. 14, 2024. / Photo: RFA

Why Tibet Matters: Significance of Tibet in Geopolitics discussed ahead of the 65th anniversary of the Tibetan National Uprising of 1959

London | 7th March 2024 | By Tsering Passang

On Wednesday, 6th March, ‘Why Tibet Matters’ – an important topic chosen for a public discourse was held in an English town of Woolwich, which the local Tibetans say had historical connection with the independent Tibet over a century ago. 

Woolwich is a thriving town in southeast London, England, within the Royal Borough of Greenwich. It is currently a home to over 100 Tibetans, which is the single largest concentration of Tibetans in one borough in the whole of UK. The town’s location on the River Thames led to its status as an important naval, military and industrial area; a role that was maintained throughout the 16th to 20th centuries. 

Photo: Jamyang

Historical connections between Tibet and Great Britain goes long back to the late 1800s and early 1900s, especially during the Great Game, when British and Russian empires had a rivalry over influence in Central Asia, primarily in Afghanistan, Persia, and Tibet.

For the isolated Tibetan Buddhists, the Younghusband Expedition to Tibet (1903-04) gave them the first taste of what a powerful western military force was like. Britain’s brief invasion of Tibet eventually taught the Tibetans a lesson that one cannot remain in isolation in this interdependent world. So, after nearly three years of exile in India, on 13th February 1913, His Holiness the 13th Dalai Lama made the Decree on Tibet’s Independence upon his return to Lhasa, Tibet’s capital.

As Britain was willing to aid the Tibetans, as part of modernising Tibet, the 13th Dalai Lama’s experiment with modern education resulted in the British welcoming four young Tibetans from Lhasa, dubbed ‘Rugby Boys’, aged between 12 and 15, in April 1913. Two of the young boys also received some training in Woolwich – at the Royal Military Academy and the Royal Arsenal.

Photo: Jamyang

After long negotiations, Great Britain and Tibet signed The Simla Treaty of 1913-14, which also included the McMohan Lines, the demarcation of today’s border between India and Tibet. Tibetans still abide by this signed treaty with a foreign country, which was negotiated by Henry McMahon, foreign secretary of British India and the chief British negotiator of the conference at Simla. However, since China’s illegal occupation of Tibet in the 1950s, Communist China has been causing real problems in the Indo-Tibet border region, which has today resulted in the deployments of over a million military personnel and sophisticated military hardwares on both sides, readying for war. 

Watch the proceedings, filmed by Londonney here:

Speakers who took part in this discourse:

  • Tsering Passang, Founder and Chair, Global Alliance for Tibet & Persecuted Minorities; Former Chairman of Tibetan Community in Britain
  • Damian Sirso, UK Coordinator, Voluntary Tibet Advocacy Group (V-TAG)
  • Ugyan Norbu, Former General Secretary of Tibet Society & Relief Fund of the UK; Former Treasurer of Tibetan Community in Britain
  • Dr. Tara Urquhart, Culture Secretary and Youth Coordinator, Tibetan Community in Britain
  • Phuntsok Norbu, Former Vice Chairman of Tibetan Community in Britain; Former Vice President of Regional Tibetan Youth Congress-Chandigarh, moderated this panel discussion.
Photo: Jamyang

Before the welcome and opening remark, the organisers released a short 8-minute video in reflection of China’s occupation of Tibet as well as the continued suppression of religious freedom and enforced colonial-style residential schooling for Tibetan children from the age of 6 to 18 with the long term goal of annihilation of the Tibetan language, identity, culture and history.

The free event held at Woolwich-Tramshed, was voluntarily organised and sponsored by Ugyan Norbu, Phuntsok Norbu, Jamyang, (Former Council Member – Campaign Coordinator, Web Designer and Administrator – Tibetan Community in Britain), and Tsering Passang to promote the Tibetan issue through public discourse.

A public discourse: Why Tibet Matters at Tramshed Woolwich London / By Tenzin Dhargyal

Tibetan National Uprising Day

Following the illegal invasion of Tibet by Communist China in the 1950s, the present 14th Dalai Lama was forced into exile in India, where the Tibetan leader established Tibet’s ‘Government-in-exile’ – officially known as the ‘Central Tibetan Administration’. Some 80,000 Tibetans followed their leader into exile.

Each year on 10th March, Tibetans commemorate the National Uprising Day of 1959 in Lhasa, Tibet’s capital. For more, please read Keeping The Flame Alive: Why Tibetans Worldwide Commemorate March 10th

#RFAExclusive: China arrests more than 1,000 Tibetans protesting Chinese dam project

Detainees are told to bring bedding and food, suggesting they will not be released soon, sources say.

By Kalden Lodoe and Tenzin Pema for RFA Tibetan
2024.02.23

Police on Friday arrested more than 1,000 Tibetans, including monks from at least two local monasteries, in southwestern China’s Sichuan province after they protested the construction of a dam expected to destroy six monasteries and force the relocation of two villages, two sources from inside Tibet told Radio Free Asia.

The arrested individuals – both monks and local residents – are being held in various places throughout Dege county in Kardze Tibetan Prefecture because the police do not have a single place to detain them, said the sources who requested anonymity for safety reasons.

Those arrested have been forced to bring their own bedding and tsampa – a staple food for Tibetans that can be used to sustain themselves for long periods of time, the sources said.

“That police are asking Tibetans to bring their own tsampa and bedding is a sign that they will not be released anytime soon,” one of the sources said.

On Thursday, Feb. 22, Chinese authorities deployed specially trained armed police in Kardze’s Upper Wonto village region to arrest more than 100 Tibetan monks from Wonto and Yena monasteries along with local residents, many of whom were beaten and injured, and later admitted to Dege County Hospital for medical treatment, sources said.

Citizen videos from Thursday, shared exclusively with RFA, show Chinese officials in black uniforms forcibly restraining monks, who can be heard crying

Following news of the mass arrests, many Tibetans from Upper Wonto village who work in other parts of the country returned to their hometown and visited the detention centers to call for the release of the arrested Tibetans, sources said. They, too, were arrested. 

The Dege County Hospital did not immediately return RFA’s requests for comment.

The Chinese Embassy in Washington hasn’t commented on the arrests other than in a statement issued Thursday that said the country respects the rule of law.

“China protects the legitimate rights and interests of Chinese nationals in accordance with the law,” the statement said.

Massive dam project

The arrests followed days of protests and appeals by local Tibetans since Feb. 14 for China to stop the construction of the Gangtuo hydropower station.

RFA reported on Feb. 15 that at least 300 Tibetans gathered outside Dege County Town Hall to protest the building of the Gangtuo dam, which is part of a massive 13-tier hydropower complex on the Drichu River with a total planned capacity 13,920 megawatts. 

The dam project is on the Drichu River, called Jinsha in Chinese, which is located on the upper reaches of the Yangtze, one of China’s most important waterways. 

Local Tibetans have been particularly distraught that the construction of the hydropower station will result in the forced resettlement of two villages – Upper Wonto and Shipa villages – and six key monasteries in the area  – Yena, Wonto, and Khardho in Wangbuding township in Dege county, and Rabten, Gonsar and Tashi in the Tibetan Autonomous Region, sources told RFA.

Sources on Friday also confirmed that some of the arrested monks with poor health conditions were allowed to return to their monasteries. 

However, the monasteries – which include Wonto Monastery, known for its ancient murals dating back to the 13th century – remained desolate on the eve of Chotrul Duchen, or the Day of Miracles, which is commemorated on the 15th day of the first month of the Tibetan New Year, or Losar, and marks the celebration of a series of miracles performed by the Buddha.

“In the past, monks of Wonto Monastery would traditionally preside over large prayer gatherings and carry out all the religious activities,” said one of the sources. “This time, the monasteries are quiet and empty. … It’s very sad to see such monasteries of historical importance being prepared for destruction. The situation is the same at Yena Monastery.” 

Protests elsewhere

Tibetans in exile have been holding mass demonstrations in various parts of the world, including in Dharamsala, India, home to the exiled Tibetan spiritual leader, the Dalai Lama. 

In the past week, Tibetans have demonstrated before the Chinese embassies, including those in New York and Switzerland, with more such protests and solidarity campaigns planned in Canada and other countries. 

“The events in Derge are an example of Beijing’s destructive policies in Tibet,” said Kai Müller, managing director of the International Campaign for Tibet, in a statement on Friday. “The Chinese regime tramples on the rights of Tibetans and ruthlessly and irretrievably destroys valuable Tibetan cultural assets.”

“Beijing’s development and infrastructure projects are not only a threat to Tibetans, but also to regional security, especially when it comes to water supplies to affected Asian countries,” he added.

Human Rights Watch told RFA that it is monitoring the development but that information from inside Tibet is extremely rare given China’s tight surveillance and restrictions imposed on information flow. 

“People who send information out and videos like this face imprisonment and torture,” said Maya Wang, the group’s interim China director. 

“Even calling families in the diaspora are reasons for imprisonment,” she said. “What we do see now are actually … typical scenes of repression in Tibet, but we don’t often get to see [what] repression looks like in Tibet anymore.”

Additional reporting by Pelbar, Yeshi Dawa, Tashi Wangchuk, Palden Gyal and Sonam Lhamo for RFA Tibetan. Edited by Roseanne Gerin and Malcolm Foster.

Useful links:

Radio Free Asia (English)

Radio Free Asia (Tibetan)

English Town Hall to raise Tibet Flag in show of support and solidarity with the Tibetan people

The London Royal Borough of Greenwich (RBG) will once again raise the Tibetan National Flag on Wednesday, 6th March 2024 at 9.30am at Woolwich Town Hall in show of support and solidarity with the people of Tibet for their peaceful freedom struggle.

Photo file: outside the Town Hall, Woolwich

Over 100,000 Tibetans worldwide are expected to commemorate the 65th anniversary of the Tibetan National Uprising Day of 1959 on 10th March this year. Read Tsering Passang’s detailed account on Why Tibetans worldwide commemorate March 10th.

The Royal Borough of Greenwich’s Mayor and the Deputy Leader will take part in the flag raising ceremony, amongst other councillors and officials, in the presence of local Tibetans, invited guests and friends, which is followed by a reception hosted by The Mayor. The Tibetan National Anthem will be sung when the Tibet Flag is raised and the Tibetans will also pray for World Peace outside the Town Hall.

This annual Tibet Flag Raising is organised by the Mayor’s Office, Royal Borough of Greenwich (RBG) and the Greenwich Tibetan Association (GTA). This London borough is home to over 100 Tibetans, the largest hub of Tibetans in a single borough in the whole of the UK.

Tsering Passang, who has been coordinating the Tibet Flag Raising, said: “We are once again delighted that the Mayor and the Deputy Leader of the Royal Borough of Greenwich will raise the Tibet Flag in show of their continued support and solidarity with the Tibetan people. In China-occupied Tibet, Tibetans are still being persecuted for their basic beliefs, including free speech. For Tibetans, this Tibet Flag raising is a noble act of support and solidarity by the Royal Borough of Greenwich. It sends the right message to China’s brutal regime that the UK stands with the people of Tibet for their freedom, justice, and human rights. On behalf of the Greenwich Tibetan Association and all Tibetans, I wish to thank the Mayor, the Deputy Leader and the Royal Borough of Greenwich for their steadfast support and solidarity with the people of Tibet. We need your continued support until freedom is restored in Tibet.”

The Tibet Flag was first raised at the Woolwich Town Hall in London in September 2015 to honour and welcome His Holiness the Dalai Lama to the Royal Borough of Greenwich. The Tibetan spiritual leader gave public talks and Buddhist teachings to over 10,000 people at The O2 Centre in September 2015, which falls within the boundaries of the Royal Borough of Greenwich.

China’s illegal occupation of Tibet subsequently forced the Nobel Peace laureate and Tibet’s spiritual leader His Holiness the Dalai Lama into exile in India in March 1959, where he set up the Central Tibetan Administration (de facto Tibet’s Government-in-exile).

Other Events – March 2024

6th March 2024: Why Tibet Matters – A Public Discourse on Tibet to Remember the 65th Anniversary of the Tibetan National Uprising of 1959

March 10th 2024: London protest to mark the 65th anniversary of the Tibetan National Uprising Day of 1959, Communist China’s aggression on peaceful Tibetans

Office of Tibet-London’s inaccurate and misleading claim must be corrected: Tibetan Losar Celebration was first held in the UK Parliament in 2018, not in 2024

(By Tsering Passang, a concerned Tibetan in London)

After careful consideration, I decided to post this on my blog to put the record straight in public for future references.

The Tibetan Losar Celebration in the UK Parliament was first held in 2018, and not in 2024, as wrongly reported/claimed by the London-based Office of Tibet.

I sent my letter (see below) to Tibetan media houses and other key stakeholders, yesterday, 21st February 2024, who unwittingly aided the spread of these inaccuracies through their news coverage and interview with the concerned CTA official based in the Office of Tibet-London.

The Voice of Tibet, Radio Free Asia and Voice of America all agreed to look into their reporting and address it accordingly. As of this morning, Tibet.net has only amended the headline of the news article in question but the factual inaccuracy still remains in the main article. In an ideal situation, the London-based Office of Tibet should have immediately rectified the inaccuracy, by issuing clarification notes to the media houses and other stakeholders.

If inaccuracies are not rectified, one way or another, in 50 or 100 years down the line future generations (Tibetans or non Tibetans) will believe the wrong reportage that the first Tibetan Losar celebration was held in UK Parliament in 2024, when it was actually in 2018. My only intention here is to present the facts. If still unconvinced, I have suggested them to contact the Offices of Tim Loughton MP and Chris Law MP, co-chairs of APPG Tibet.

If the Office of Tibet-London and others don’t rectify the inaccuracies on their platforms having presented the facts by someone who was closely associated with the Losar celebration event first held in the UK Parliament in 2018, then I am afraid we are recording a wrong historical event.

21st February 2024

FAO: Editors and Directors of

Tibet.net

Office of Tibet, London

Radio Free Asia (RFA) Tibetan Program

Voice of America (VOA) Tibetan Program

Voice of Tibet (VOT)

Free Tibet

Tibetan Community UK

International Campaign for Tibet

CC: Tim Loughton MP, Chris Law MP

Dear Editors / Directors,

I hope this letter finds you well. I am writing to express my concern regarding a recent news article published and reported by your organisations and media outlets – Tibetan New Year Celebrated in the UK Parliament for the First Time. This news was first published in Tibet.net on 8th February 2024, which was filed by the London-based Office of Tibet. Having seen this news on your platforms, I also came across certain media interviews with Office of Tibet-Secretary Lochoe Samten-la who reiterated and confirmed this false claim. Furthermore, it appeared that the London-based CTA official also repeated this misleading claim during the Losar celebrations in UK Parliament on 7th February and at the Stratford Town Hall on 10th February.

After reading the piece in Tibet.net, I felt compelled to address this inaccuracy and misleading information presented in the article, a false narrative started in London. Needless to mention so many Tibetans and others, including guests who participated in the first Losar celebration event in Parliament in 2018 have expressed to me their concern and disappointment regarding this misleading and inaccurate news.

Such misleading information created and distributed by CTA officials could jeopardise the reputations built over the decades by many. This inaccurate claim may seem small and simple in one sense, but this must be corrected with immediate effect for the sake of truth, honesty and integrity of these important offices, which have important roles to play for our Tibetan freedom struggle.

The Losar Reception was organised by The All-Party Parliamentary Group (APPG) on Tibet and the Tibet Society, its Secretariat, with the full support and cooperation of Honourable Tim Loughton MP and his Office, led by his senior staff Kari Sargeant. In the absence of Tim Loughton MP that day, the other Co-Chair of APPG Tibet – Chris Law MP hosted the Losar Reception. Four visiting Buddhist monks from Gyuto Monastery in India chanted Buddhist prayers for World Peace and members of the Tibetan Community Dance Group presented cultural performances with speeches by MPs and Tibet Society’s executives. Tibet Society’s Advocacy Officer Gloria Montgomery liaised with Tim’s Office and successfully organised this historic Losar Reception event in the UK Parliament. In addition to facilitating the Gyuto monks for this special cultural event in the Parliament, Tenzin Dakpa, proprietor of Kailash Momo Restaurant sponsored the refreshments for the Losar Reception. 

The initial idea of the Tibetan Losar Reception in the UK Parliament was conceived in 2016 and finally got to implement in 2018 after the Tibet Society Council’s appointment of Tsering Passang as its Special Adviser. (See Tsering Passang’s initial communication with Tim Loughton MP and his office, sent on 21st December 2017.)

I view it as essential for the Tibet.net and media houses like yours to uphold the highest standards of journalism by ensuring accuracy and fairness in reporting. In this case, the inaccuracies, reported by the London-based Office of Tibet, present a distorted fact of the events and have already misled readers, potentially damaging the reputation of individuals or all organisations involved, including the media houses. In an ideal situation, the London-based Office of Tibet should have immediately rectified the inaccuracy, by issuing clarification notes to the media houses and other stakeholders.

Someone, who has long been campaigning for truth and justice for Tibet and the Tibetan people, including against the BBC for running their distorted facts on our spiritual leader His Holiness the Dalai Lama in 2023, their action encouraged other local and national media houses coverage on the subject, it is my duty to urge you all concerned, especially the CTA offices, to rectify the errors published / covered on your platforms by issuing a correction or clarification in a timely manner. Doing so will not only uphold the integrity of your media houses but also demonstrate your commitment to providing accurate and reliable information to your readership and audience.

As a concerned reader and seeker of truth and justice, I trust that you will take appropriate action to address this matter promptly for the sake of public records and for future references. If you require any further information or clarification regarding the events in question, please do not hesitate to contact me.

Thank you for your attention to this matter. I look forward to seeing the necessary corrections made in your outlets. I’ll appreciate a copy of your corrections.

Sincerely,

Tsering Passang

A Concerned Tibetan in London;

Special Adviser, Tibet Society (2017 – 2018);

Chairman, Tibetan Community in Britain (2014-2016)

https://www.tibetsun.com/news_you_witness/2018/02/23/reception-in-uk-parliament-to-celebrate-tibetan-new-year

Reception in UK Parliament to celebrate Tibetan New Year

By Riki Hyde-Chambers | Tibet Society

LONDON, UK, 23 February 2018:

On the evening of 21 February 201, Tibet Society and the All-Party Parliamentary Group for Tibet (APPGT) hosted a joint reception to celebrate the Tibetan New Year (Losar) in the UK Parliament.

The reception included a performance by monks from the Gyuto Monastery in India who are world renowned for their deep harmonic chanting of traditional Tibetan prayer, as well as a performance by members of the Tibetan Community in Britain, Jamyang Dorjee and Tenzin Samphel.

The Gyuto order was originally based in Lhasa, Tibet. Following the Chinese invasion in 1950, thousands of men, women, and children were massacred. Only 59 Gyuto monks were able to escape and followed His Holiness the Dalai Lama into exile in India.

Speaking at the reception, Tsering Tashi, vice-chair of Tibet Society, said: 

“Today, there are over 500 monks living in the Gyuto monastery in India, and through their hard work and dedication, they have been able to keep alive the Gyuto’s unique tradition of overtone prayer chanting dating back more than 6000 years.” He also added that the Gyuto monks “are and have been the most wonderful ambassadors for the just cause of Tibet, Tibetan culture, and world peace.”

During the event, the Gyuto monks expressed their concern at the ongoing human rights situation in Tibet:

“We are deeply concerned at the lack of religious freedom in Tibet, which is currently occupied by China. We would like to take this opportunity to urge all the parliamentarians as well as the UK government to press China to respect the right to freedom of religion and belief for all peoples in China and in our Tibetan homeland.”

Co-Chair of the APPGT, The Rt Hon Chris Law MP, encouraged his fellow MPs to join the group in promoting and protecting human rights in Tibet and reiterated his firm belief in the right of the Tibetan people to self-determination.

The reception ended with President of Tibet Society, The Rt Hon Norman Baker, handing out khatas (a Tibetan scarf offering) and certificates to MPs, diplomatic staff, and highly-valued supporters of the Tibetan cause.

This was the first-ever Parliamentary Losar reception. It was hosted by Chris Law MP, Co-Chair of the APPGT, and compered by Rt. Hon. Norman Baker, President of Tibet Society. We hope this to be an annual event going forward.

In attendance: MPs, Representatives of various diplomatic embassies, International Campaign for Tibet, Free Tibet, Tibetan Community of Britain, Lelung Dharma Centre, and members of the Tibet Society.

Tibet Society’s Special Adviser – Tsering Passang’s communication re: Tibetan Losar Reception in UK Parliament with Tim Loughton MP and his staff Kari Sargeant – sent on 21st December 2017:

Dear Tim Loughton and Kari, 

Good morning! May I first thank you both for your wonderful support during Sikyong Dr Lobsang Sangay’s recent engagement in the parliament. I always appreciate your vital contribution to keeping the issue of Tibet alive through your good offices. 

After speaking to Riki and Tsering Tashi yesterday I am pleased to confirm now that we have secured the availability of the five visiting Gyuto Monks from India, who are currently on UK Tour of “Open Mind, Loving Heart” (please see below for their background), for the Losar Reception (Tibetan New Year celebration) at the Parliament anytime between 19th and 24th February 2018. I hope this gives us plenty of options for room booking.

The Tibetan New Year falls on 16th February next year. Riki suggests the reception starting at 6 pm. The Gyuto Monks are famous for their deep throat chanting, Richard Gere is a big-time supporter of the monks especially with their US tours. 

Gyuto Monks chanting and Sand Mandala creation: In addition to the Sacred Buddhist chanting, the monks can do a live exhibition of the creation of the Sand Mandala at the reception, so I suggest, if it’s possible, please book the room for one and half hours for the reception (this includes Tim’s welcome address, monks chanting and thank you note from Riki or Tsering Tashi and enjoyment of food and drinks whilst watching the sand mandala being created). It would be great if we can get access to the room an hour before the event for the preparation. 

With regards to the detailed arrangement, we shall discuss in the coming weeks, after the New Year, but our initial thought is that food/drinks are to be placed order in-house catering, and few additional bits for e.g. Khabsey (Tibetan cookies) and Dresil (ceremonial rice) are to be brought from outside if this is allowed. 

The marking of the Losar (Tibetan New Year) is a celebration of Tibetan culture, a show of respect, support and recognition of the peaceful Tibetan culture, a joyful occasion too! This can be a good way of engaging with our parliamentarians, their assistants and other key stakeholders. 

We hope the Losar event becomes an annual event for the APPGT and Tibet Society in the parliament as part of a continued engagement with key stakeholders (enabling the Tibetan issue being kept alive through this event). In the US, the State Department officially hosts the Tibetan Losar in a show of support to Tibetan culture. 

Invitees: In addition to the MPs invitation and concerned FO officials as well as other key stakeholders, we would like to invite a limited number of the Tibet Society supporters as part of ongoing engagements. 

I am copying this email to Gloria, in addition to Riki and Tsering Tashi, who is our key staff and liaising with the key contacts for this special event.  

If you require any information, please feel free to email me or call me on 07927 376 532. Finally, I wish you all a Merry Christmas and a Very Happy New Year!

Best wishes,


Tsering Passang

Special Adviser, Tibet Society

RFA Tibetan

The Radio Free Asia (RFA) Tibetan noted its oversight and issued its Correction immediately. Here is the link to the news article: https://www.rfa.org/tibetan/sargyur/losar-uk-02092024154733.html

Tibet.net

Received a note from Tibet.net Editor confirming the correction of the earlier inaccurate reporting. Here is the link to the corrected news article: https://tibet.net/tibetan-new-year-celebrated-in-the-uk-parliament/

TibetTV

The misreporting broadcast by TibetTV still remains uncorrected. Have not seen any note to this effect. Here is the link to the original inaccurate broadcast: https://youtu.be/G3ZlImgJz_o

VOA Tibetan

It appears that the VOA Tibetan, a leading Tibet news agency based in Washington DC, has yet to rectify its inaccurate reporting of this news. The VOA’s interview of false claim by the CTA official is still available at: https://www.voatibetan.com/a/tibetan-new-year-celebrated-in-the-uk-parliament-for-the-first-time—2024-tibetan-lunar-year-2151-/7480625.html

Author’s Note: “If inaccuracies are not rectified, one way or another, in 50 or 100 years down the line future generations (Tibetans or non Tibetans) will believe the wrong reportage that the first Tibetan Losar celebration was held in UK Parliament in 2024 when it was actually in 2018. Having already presented facts to the concerned stakeholders and if they still refuse to take corrective actions, I am afraid we are recording a wrong historical account of this Tibetan cultural event held in the UK Parliament.” Tsering Passang.

March 10th 2024: London protest to mark the 65th anniversary of the Tibetan National Uprising Day of 1959, Communist China’s aggression on peaceful Tibetans

On Sunday, 10th March, the annual protest and rally will be held in central London to commemorate the 65th anniversary of the Tibetan National Uprising Day of 1959 in Lhasa. Over 100,000 Tibetans in diaspora and their supporters across some 22 countries will mark this poignant day in Tibet’s history.

Read Tsering Passang’s piece – Keeping The Flame Alive: Why Tibetans Worldwide Commemorate March 10th.

Gathering Point: Tibetans and their supporters will first gather opposite 10 Downing Street (UK Prime Minister’s Residence), London SW1A 2AA (from 10.30am). After a rally, which includes speeches, the protesters will then march to the Chinese Embassy (49-51 Portland Place, London WB 1JL) via Trafalgar Square, Piccadilly Circus and Oxford Circus (around midday).

Rally opposite Chinese Embassy: The rally opposite the Chinese Embassy, includes Buddhist prayers for World Peace and speeches from Tibetans and invited guests (around 1pm.

Protesters will chant loud slogans such as “Free Tibet”, “Human Rights in Tibet” and “China: Stop Killing Tibetans” – chanting these phrases in China’s occupied Tibet will end up in prison, facing long sentences. Today, more than 1500 Tibetans are serving prison sentences in Chinese prisons for simply exercising free speech.

Tibetan Commemoration Event at Indian YMCA: After the rally, the annual Tibetan commemoration event will be held at the Indian YMCA, 41 Fitzroy Square, London, W1T 6AQ (starts at 3pm), where Tibetan food will also be served. This official commemoration function at the Indian YMCA will be participated by the Office of Tibet, London, academicians and guests.

This year’s day-long commemoration will involve Tibet groups, including Free Tibet, V-TAG (UK) and Students for Free Tibet (UK) and support from International Tibet Network and Tibet Action Institute (UK wing).

Join the protest and show your support and solidarity with the Tibetan people.

Tibet Lobby Action Week (7th – 11th March): Ahead of the UK General Elections, the Tibetan Community UK and Tibet groups in the UK will kickstart Tibet Lobby Action Week from 7th to 11th March this year. The different groups involved in the lobby action will provide materials, including key ‘Asks’ in early March. Your support and participation is key to a successful Tibet Lobby Action Week. Please visit their websites!

Useful links:

Free Tibet www.freetibet.org

Tibet Action Institutewww.tibetaction.net

International Tibet Networkhttps://tibetnetwork.org/

Tibetan Community UK www.tibetancommunityuk.net

Students for Free Tibet (UK)https://www.facebook.com/SFTUK

Voluntary Tibet Advocacy Group (V-TAG)www.v-tag.net

13th Feb 1913 – 13th Feb 2024: Why Tibetans Commemorate the 111th Anniversary of the Proclamation of Tibet’s Independence?

In his Proclamation of the Tibetan Independence, on 13th February 1913, His Holiness the Great XIII Dalai Lama, declared: “Tibet is a country with rich natural resources; but it is not scientifically advanced like other lands. We are a small, religious, and independent nation. To keep up with the rest of the world, we must defend our country. In view of past invasions by foreigners, our people may have to face certain difficulties, which they must disregard. To safeguard and maintain the independence of our country, one and all should voluntarily work hard. Our subject citizens residing near the borders should be alert and keep the government informed by special messenger of any suspicious developments. Our subjects must not create major clashes between two nations because of minor incidents.

The proclamation was made after the Great Thirteenth Dalai Lama returned to Tibet from exile in India, in January 1913. At the time of the Dalai Lama’s return to his landlocked Tibetan Kingdom, the Manchu dynasty had been dissolved in the course of the Chinese revolution. For nearly forty years afterwards, Tibetans enjoyed self-rule – only for it to come to an end in 1949, after Communist China’s Mao Tsetung declared “peaceful liberation” of Tibetans from the foreign imperialists.

For Tibetans, Mao’s declaration was not only a brutal attack on Buddhist religion and the Tibetan culture but an illegal occupation of their peaceful nation by the giant neighbour, People’s Republic of China. The Tibetan people have a proud history of independence with the successive Dalai Lamas enjoying spiritual patronage over Mongols and Chinese emperors.

Just as it did more than a thousand years ago, today, a doring (pillar) stands outside the Jokhang Temple in Lhasa, Tibet’s capital city. On its stone sides the Tibet-China Treaty of 821-822 AD is carved, signifying the legacy of a free and independent Tibet.

“Tibetans shall be happy in the land of Tibet, and Chinese shall be happy in the land of China,” reads a key text in the treaty, clearly describing the borders between Tibet and China.

For those who haven’t read the Proclamation of Independence Issued by the Great XIII Dalai Lama, please see below:

PROCLAMATION ISSUED BY H.H. THE DALAI LAMA XIII, ON THE EIGHTH DAY OF THE FIRST MONTH OF THE WATER-OX YEAR (1913)

Translation of the Tibetan Text

“I, the Dalai Lama, most omniscient possessor of the Buddhist faith, whose title was conferred by the Lord Buddha’s command from the glorious land of India, speak to you as follows:

I am speaking to all classes of Tibetan people. Lord Buddha, from the glorious country of India, prophesied that the reincarnations of Avalokitesvara, through successive rulers from the early religious kings to the present day, would look after the welfare of Tibet.

During the time of Genghis Khan and Altan Khan of the Mongols, the Ming dynasty of the Chinese, and the Ch’ing Dynasty of the Manchus, Tibet and China cooperated on the basis of benefactor and priest relationship. A few years ago, the Chinese authorities in Szechuan and Yunnan endeavored to colonize our territory. They brought large numbers of troops into central Tibet on the pretext of policing the trade marts. I, therefore, left Lhasa with my ministers for the Indo-Tibetan border, hoping to clarify to the Manchu emperor by wire that the existing relationship between Tibet and China had been that of patron and priest and had not been based on the subordination of one to the other. There was no other choice for me but to cross the border, because Chinese troops were following with the intention of taking me alive or dead.

On my arrival in India, I dispatched several telegrams to the Emperor; but his reply to my demands was delayed by corrupt officials at Peking. Meanwhile, the Manchu empire collapsed. The Tibetans were encouraged to expel the Chinese from central Tibet. I, too, returned safely to my rightful and sacred country, and I am now in the course of driving out the remnants of Chinese troops from DoKham in Eastern Tibet. Now, the Chinese intention of colonizing Tibet under the patron-priest relationship has faded like a rainbow in the sky. Having once again achieved for ourselves a period of happiness and peace, I have now allotted to all of you the following duties to be carried out without negligence:

  1. Peace and happiness in this world can only be maintained by preserving the faith of Buddhism. It is, therefore, essential to preserve all Buddhist institutions in Tibet, such as the Jokhang temple and Ramoche in Lhasa, Samye, and Traduk in southern Tibet, and the three great monasteries, etc.
  2. The various Buddhist sects in Tibet should be kept in a distinct and pure form. Buddhism should be taught, learned, and meditated upon properly. Except for special persons, the administrators of monasteries are forbidden to trade, loan money, deal in any kind of livestock, and/or subjugate another’s subjects.
  3. The Tibetan government’s civil and military officials, when collecting taxes or dealing with their subject citizens, should carry out their duties with fair and honest judgment so as to benefit the government without hurting the interests of the subject citizens. Some of the central government officials posted at Ngari Korsum in western Tibet, and Do Kham in eastern Tibet, are coercing their subject citizens to purchase commercial goods at high prices and have imposed transportation rights exceeding the limit permitted by the government. Houses, properties and lands belonging to subject citizens have been confiscated on the pretext of minor breaches of the law. Furthermore, the amputation of citizens’ limbs has been carried out as a form of punishment. Henceforth, such severe punishments are forbidden.
  4. Tibet is a country with rich natural resources; but it is not scientifically advanced like other lands. We are a small, religious, and independent nation. To keep up with the rest of the world, we must defend our country. In view of past invasions by foreigners, our people may have to face certain difficulties, which they must disregard. To safeguard and maintain the independence of our country, one and all should voluntarily work hard. Our subject citizens residing near the borders should be alert and keep the government informed by special messenger of any suspicious developments. Our subjects must not create major clashes between two nations because of minor incidents.
  5. Tibet, although thinly populated, is an extensive country. Some local officials and landholders are jealously obstructing other people from developing vacant lands, even though they are not doing so themselves. People with such intentions are enemies of the State and our progress. From now on, no one is allowed to obstruct anyone else from cultivating whatever vacant lands are available. Land taxes will not be collected until three years have passed; after that the land cultivator will have to pay taxes to the government and to the landlord every year, proportionate to the rent. The land will belong to the cultivator.

Your duties to the government and to the people will have been achieved when you have executed all that I have said here. This letter must be posted and proclaimed in every district of Tibet, and a copy kept in the records of the offices in every district.

From the Potala Palace.

(Seal of the Dalai Lama)”

Source (and further reading): Tibet: A Political History, Tsepon W.D. Shagapda, New Haven, 1967, pp. 246-248.

Useful explanation on the same subject by US-based Tibetan Author and Rangzen Advocate, Jamyang Norbu-la:

English Translation of 13Th Dalai Lama’s Decree

Why Tibet Matters བོད་གལ་གནད་ཅན་དུ་ཆགས་པའི་རྒྱུ་མཚན།

A Public Discourse on Tibet to Remember the 65th Anniversary of the Tibetan National Uprising of 1959

Why Tibet Matters བོད་གལ་གནད་ཅན་དུ་ཆགས་པའི་རྒྱུ་མཚན།

‘Why Tibet Matters’ is a public forum aiming to raise awareness about China’s unlawful occupation of Tibet and to educate Tibetan youth and new audiences about the ongoing freedom struggle of the Tibetan people.

Multiple Tibetan generations will lead this public discourse. Ugyan Norbu (born in Tibet), Tsering Passang (born in Nepal), Damian Sirso (born in Europe) and Dr Tara Urquhart (born in Europe) will share their perspectives on this important subject. There will be an open mic when the audience is encouraged to share their perspectives as well as ask questions to the speakers.

This is a free event, organised and sponsored by several individuals at their own initiative. Light refreshments served.

Organisers:

  • Ugyan Norbu, Former General Secretary of Tibet Society; Former Treasurer of Tibetan Community in Britain
  • Jamyang, Former Council Member (Campaign Coordinator, Web Designer and Administrator), Tibetan Community in Britain
  • Phuntsok Norbu, Former Vice Chairman of Tibetan Community in Britain
  • Tsering Passang, Founder and Chair, Global Alliance for Tibet & Persecuted Minorities; Former Chairman of Tibetan Community in Britain

Background:

Tibet is still under the illegal occupation of Communist China. This year marks the 65th anniversary of the Tibetan National Uprising. His Holiness the 14th Dalai Lama was forced into exile in India in March 1959, where the Tibetan Leader has been residing ever since. The people of Tibet have endured unimaginable hardships since China’s illegal occupation of Tibet through brute force in the 1950s.

Over a million Tibetans have died as a direct result of China’s illegal invasion. More than 98% of ancient Tibetan Buddhist cultural heritage and learning centres, including monasteries and nunneries, were all destroyed. China termed its invasion of Tibet a “peaceful liberation” of Tibetans from foreign imperialists. Persecution of Tibetans in their homelands continue to this day with renewed campaign of DNA collections as well as forced admission of nearly a million Tibetan children in China’s colonial-style residential schools with a long-term goal of annihilating the Tibetan identity, language and culture.

New report reveals chilling effect of China’s weaponisation of big data in Tibet

February 7, 2024 / By Tibet Watch

A new report, released today by the research organisations Turquoise Roof and Tibet Watch uncovers new and alarming evidence of the Chinese government’s deepening digital intrusion into Tibetan lives through the mandatory installation of an app on smartphones at police checkpoints. 

Weaponsing Big Data

Weaponising Big Data: Decoding China’s Digital Surveillance in Tibet sheds new light on the reach of Party mechanisms into the personal sphere. This is not only changing the way people communicate, but creating a society-wide chilling effect on the way they think, feel, and relate to each other, in many cases leading to a complete breakdown of contact. 

The integration of a panoply of advanced technologies in Tibet  – AI-driven systems fusing facial recognition with internet browsing and app-based monitoring, DNA and genomic surveillance, and GIS tracking data – underlines the emergence of a terrifying approach to governance in the 21st century. It uses machine learning to power systems that prioritise state control and suppression over individual liberties and self-determination.   

The Turquoise Roof team conducted a dynamic analysis of the Android version of the app installed by Chinese police, in order to assess the likelihood that data collected could feed into broader control mechanisms, including integration with databases managed by the Criminal Investigation Bureau, reflecting wider strategies of surveillance and oversight in the region.

The report also investigates a big data policing platform known as the ‘Tibet Underworld Criminal Integrated Intelligence Application Platform’. Analysis of government procurement notices revealed that this system amalgamates data from various existing Public Security Bureau systems in the Tibetan Autonomous Region (TAR) into a central Oracle database. This database system, developed on top of U.S. technology, is instrumental in a campaign that criminalises even moderate cultural and religious expression, Tibetan language study groups, and community welfare work in Tibet.

Surveillance camera in a prayer wheel, Barkor, Lhasa, 2017 / Photo: Tibet Watch

There are clear parallels in the deployment of spyware and Universal Forensic Extraction Devices (UFEDs) at police checkpoints in both Tibet and Xinjiang. Similarly, sophisticated big data analytics platforms are in operation in both regions, and although specific systems might differ, the same overarching strategy of control and suppression through intelligence-led policing is evident in both regions. 

Civilian AI-driven surveillance systems deployed in Tibet and Xinjiang originate in military Command and Control (C4ISR) systems-of-systems, and integrated PLA joint operations doctrine. Chinese software developers have acknowledged this evolution in which cities and towns where people live are treated like a battlefield.

The report is based on interviews with newly-arrived Tibetan refugees in India and other Tibetan sources, big data generated from official government sources, mobile digital forensics in the context of contemporary Tibet, and in-depth analysis of surveillance System Description Documents.

The report is released a day after the Tibetan Centre for Human Rights and Democracy published a groundbreaking report on transnational repression including, for the first time, 84 testimonies of Tibetan exiles.

Only a week ago, China faced international scrutiny over its human rights record during the fourth Universal Periodic Review (UPR) Working Group session of the United Nations Human Rights Council from 22 January to 2 February. 21 countries have raised serious concerns about rights in Tibet, with the UK and US governments criticising China’s intrusive surveillance methods.

Read the full report >>> WEAPONISING BIG DATA: DECODING CHINA’S DIGITAL SURVEILLANCE IN TIBET

Sources / Links:

Tibet Watch

Turquoise Roof

Tibetan Centre for Human Rights and Democracy

It is important to show the Chinese Communist Party that there are fierce consequences when countries flout international law

By Tim Loughton MP | February 2, 2024 | Parliament News

Tim Loughton is the Conservative MP for East Worthing and Shoreham, and was elected in 1997.

On the 23rd of January, I secured a Westminster Hall debate on the ‘Future of human rights in Hong Kong’. The timing of the debate was particularly pertinent as it coincided with China’s Universal Periodic Review (UPR) at the United Nations. The UPR is a device allowing member states of the UN Human Rights Council to peer review China’s human rights record, and the lack of. The debate allowed Parliamentarians and I to highlight the injustices affecting contemporary Hong Kong including the Chinese Government’s increasing oppression of what they deem as political threats, such as Jimmy Lai, a 76-year-old man on trial in Hong Kong under National Security Law. As one of the MPs sanctioned by the Chinese Government (CCP) and Chair of the Tibet APPG, I regularly raise longstanding concerns about human rights violations by the CCP, not least against Tibetans and Uyghurs Muslims, in Parliament.

We are now approaching the fourth year of Hong Kong’s inclusion under the notorious National Security Law (NSL), where Beijing bypassed the territory’s own Legislative Council to enforce the programme. The NSL criminalises any acts of secession, subversion, terrorism and collusion with foreign and external forces, and is completely open to the interpretation of Beijing officials. It flagrantly breaches the British-Sino Joint Declaration 1997 which saw the handover of Hong Kong to the Chinese Government, enshrining the concept of “one country, two systems”. Under this, Hong Kong was supposed to enjoy a “high degree of autonomy”, maintaining, for example its own legal system, judiciary and borders, however under current circumstances those commitments have turned into hollow words.

Beijing’s clampdown on civil liberties has manifested itself in a multitude of ways. The breakdown of the Joint Declaration does not contain any penalties for China if it breaches the agreement, the lack of disincentives to comply have only emboldened the CCP’s continuous breach of international and joint laws. As of December 2023, 285 people have been arrested, among whom 172 were prosecuted for allegedly “endangering national security”. Moreover, the law has also led to the closure of more than 100 NGO and civil society groups, including Amnesty International and Human Rights Watch. By encompassing Hong Kong within NSL, the Chinese Community Party (CCP) has clearly aimed to eradicate any form of political opponent. In 2024, Hong Kong now has one of the fastest-growing political prisoner populations in the world, rivalling authoritarian states such a Cuba, Myanmar, and Belarus. The astronomical rise in political prisoners (from 0 to 1,775 between 2020 and 2023), has seen the persecution of prominent pro-democracy figures including politician and social activist, Lee Cheuk-yan, professor of Law at Hong Kong University, Benny Tai, and of course British citizen and Apple Daily (pro-democracy) media owner, Jimmy Lai. Jimmy Lai is currently under trial for sedition and collusion with foreign powers under NSL demonstrating how the law is one of the most egregious examples of the intolerance, illiberalism and injustice faced by Hong Kongers since CCP clampdown in June 2020.

Beijing’s clampdown and increased centralised control was a reaction to a resurgence of pro-democracy protests, such as those in 2014 and 2019, and the success of pro-democracy politicians in the island’s 2019 local elections. Politically, the complete overhaul of Hong Kong’s electoral system, that allows for “Patriots-only” elections, has led to a complete collapse in voter turnout from 71.2% in 2019 to 27.5% in 2023. There is no greater demonstration of the disastrous impact of these laws than the mass exodus of approximately 500,000 residents leaving Hong Kong since 2021. Many of them have cited China’s stronger grip over the territory as the primary reason to leave. The Home Office launched the BNO visa scheme on 31st January 2021, according to the Home Office, as of February 2023, over 144,500 Hong Kongers had moved to the UK.

In closing the debate, I called for the UK and Ministers to work with global, democratic partners to call out and hold China accountable for its human right abuses in Hong Kong, and coordinate consequences. The UK’s progress to date has been slow, and while at last Jimmy Lai has been recognised as a British citizen, no sanctions have been made against CCP officials when sanctions against other foreign individuals and powers have been quickly enforced. It is important to show the Chinese Communist Party that there are fierce consequences when countries flout international law, strangling the golden goose that was once a beacon of liberty and entrepreneurialism.

‘Future of Tibet’ by Tsering Passang

Tsering Passang’s Presentation at The Royal Society for Asian Affairs (RSAA), London – 29 January 2024. The Tibet event was held at St. Anne’s Church, Soho, London for RSAA’s members and guests, with cooperation from the Global Alliance for Tibet & Persecuted Minorities.

Tsering Passang with Geshe Ngakrampa Thupten Sherab, Gyuto Monastery

Ladies and gentlemen, esteemed guests, and fellow advocates for justice,

Thank you for joining us today as we embark on a journey of reflection and hope, delving into the profound topic of the future prospects of Tibet. In our exploration, we find ourselves standing at a crucial intersection where the destiny of Tibet is intricately linked with the decisions and actions of nations. Today, I present to you a discourse not only on the challenges faced by Tibet but, more importantly, on the way forward – a path marked by self-determination, justice, and the preservation of the unique Tibetan identity and culture.

Understanding the Historical Tapestry

Before we delve into the prospects of Tibet’s future, it is crucial to acknowledge the historical struggle that has defined the Tibetan narrative. Tibet, a land with a rich cultural heritage and natural resources, and a history of sovereign existence, faced a seismic shift with the invasion by the People’s Republic of China in the 1950s. The forced exile of His Holiness the Dalai Lama and some 80,000 Tibetan refugees, who have remained in India since 1959, marked a tragic chapter in Tibetan history.

Tibetans, both inside Tibet and in the diaspora, have shown remarkable resilience, holding onto their unique cultural identity despite the challenges imposed by external forces, primarily under China’s illegal occupation of Tibet, for more than 70 years. Monasteries were desecrated, cultural artifacts were destroyed, and over a million Tibetans lost their lives since Communist China’s invasion of Tibet. Today, in Tibet, nearly a million Tibetan children, between the age of 4 and 18, are forcefully being admitted in China’s colonial-style residential schools with a long-term goal of annihilating the Tibetan identity, language and culture. As we examine the trajectory involving the United Kingdom, India, the United States, and European countries we must recognise the complexity of historical ties, geopolitical manoeuvring, and the aspirations of the Tibetan people’s yearning for freedom and self-determination.

Tibet’s Trajectory Involving Foreign Powers

The geopolitical trajectory involving foreign powers is intricate, shaped by historical connections, diplomatic intricacies, and the evolving dynamics of global politics. Each nation plays a unique role in the unfolding story of Tibet, and it is within this context that we explore the prospects for Tibet’s future.

1. Historical Connection with the United Kingdom

The early 20th century witnessed the Younghusband Expedition to Tibet, a historical interaction between the British and the Tibetans, when Tibet faced a brief foreign invasion with direct order from London. While formal recognition of Tibetan sovereignty remained elusive in the modern context, the historical ties between the United Kingdom and Tibet, including the signing of the 1914 Simla Treaty, are profound. As we navigate the way forward, I implore the United Kingdom to draw upon these historical connections and advocate for the rights of the Tibetan people.

As a permanent member of the United Nations, the United Kingdom, with its democratic principles and commitment to human rights, holds a unique position to champion the Tibetan cause. It is a call for the UK government to utilise its diplomatic influence and historical ties to mobilise international support for Tibet, emphasising the importance of self-determination.

2. India’s Historic Ties and Ongoing Role

India, as a neighbour and a nation with a history of cultural ties to Tibet, plays a pivotal role in the Tibetan struggle. The refuge provided to His Holiness the Dalai Lama and thousands of Tibetan refugees since 1959 established a unique bond between India and Tibet. As we envision the future, I urge India to strengthen its commitment to the Tibetan cause. Tibet’s freedom is also linked with India’s national security.

The historical ties between India and Tibet, coupled with shared democratic values, position India as a key player in advocating for the self-determination of the Tibetan people. It is a call for India to leverage its diplomatic relations with China to encourage a peaceful resolution, respecting the aspirations of Tibetans for self-determination.

3. The United States: A Beacon of Support

The United States, with its commitment to democracy and human rights, has consistently expressed support for Tibet. Bipartisan initiatives such as the Tibet Policy and Support Act (TPSA) underscore the U.S. government’s dedication to addressing the Tibetan issue and advocating for the rights of the Tibetan people.

As we discuss the prospects for Tibet’s future, I call upon the United States to continue its unwavering support. The U.S. government’s engagement with China should include a strong stance on human rights abuses, religious repression, and the preservation of Tibetan culture. Self-determination is a fundamental right that must be acknowledged and supported by nations committed to justice.

4. The Role of the European Union

The European countries, particularly the European Union, with their commitments to fundamental rights and democratic principles, are significant players in shaping global affairs. As we navigate the future of Tibet, I implore the European Union to champion the Tibetan cause on the international stage. The values that bind the EU – human dignity, cultural diversity, and self-determination – should guide its advocacy for Tibet.

The EU’s diplomatic and economic influence can contribute significantly to the self-determination of the Tibetan people. It is a call for the EU to utilise its position to engage with like-minded nations, foster alliances, and promote the cause of justice, human rights, and political resolutions for Tibet.

5. China’s Assertiveness and Global Implications

China’s assertiveness, particularly in its policies towards Tibet, has profound global implications. The invasion of Tibet in the 1950s marked a turning point, and China’s rising influence adds complexity to the Tibetan struggle. As we contemplate the prospects for Tibet’s future, it is crucial for the international community, including the UK, to recognise the broader implications of China’s actions in Tibet.

The self-determination of the Tibetan people is intricately linked to the global commitment to justice and human rights. The world must not turn a blind eye to the plight of Tibetans and the erosion of their cultural identity. It is a call for nations to consider the broader context and understand that justice for Tibet is not only a regional concern but a litmus test for the international community’s commitment to the principles of self-determination.

The Way Forward: Self-Determination and Political Resolutions

As we contemplate the way forward for Tibet, the central tenet must be the self-determination of the Tibetan people. The right to determine one’s political status and pursue economic, social, and cultural development is a fundamental principle enshrined in international law. The trajectory involving the UK, India, the United States, and the European Union must be one that respects and upholds this right.

1. International Diplomacy for Self-Determination

International diplomacy plays a crucial role in advocating for self-determination. The UK, with its historical ties to Tibet, should take a lead in mobilising the international community to recognise and support the Tibetan people’s right to self-determination. The path forward involves diplomatic efforts that emphasise the importance of respecting the will of the Tibetan people in determining their political status. 

Nations sympathetic to the Tibetan cause, including the United Kingdom, the United States, India, and the European Union, should collaborate on diplomatic initiatives that exert maximum pressure on China to engage in meaningful dialogue with Tibetan representatives. It is a call for the international community to stand united in support of the Tibetan people’s right to self-determination.

2. Human Rights Advocacy: A Pillar of Self-Determination

Human rights advocacy is intrinsic to the Tibetan struggle for self-determination. The UK, the United States, India, and the European Union must collectively condemn human rights abuses in Tibet by China’s authorities. The violation of religious freedom, cultural assimilation, and repression of dissent are stark realities that demand international attention.

As a British Tibetan, I urge the UK government to consistently raise the issue of human rights abuses in Tibet on the global stage. The right to self-determination cannot be realised in an environment where basic human rights are systematically violated. It is a call for the international community to hold China accountable for its actions in Tibet and insist on the protection of the fundamental rights of the Tibetan people.

3. Regional Collaboration for Self-Determination

Regional collaboration, particularly involving India, is crucial for the self-determination of the Tibetan people. India, with its historic ties to Tibet and commitment to democratic values, can play a pivotal role in advocating for self-determination. The path forward involves strengthening regional alliances that prioritise justice, human rights, and political resolutions for Tibet.

Collaborative efforts between India, the UK, the European Union and the United States can amplify the impact of diplomatic initiatives. I call for a united front that advocates for the self-determination of the Tibetan people within the regional context. Joint efforts should focus on encouraging China to engage in meaningful dialogue that respects the aspirations of Tibetans. Like it was before China’s invasion, Tibet as a ‘buffer’ state between India and China ensures stability and restores peace in the region.

4. Empowering the ‘Middle-Way’ Approach

The ‘Middle-Way’ Approach, advocated by the Central Tibetan Administration (aka Tibet’s Government-in-exile), offers a pragmatic path toward self-determination. It seeks genuine autonomy for Tibet within the framework of the PRC Constitution while respecting China’s territorial integrity. As we envision the future, I urge the UK and European nations to endorse and actively support the ‘Middle-Way’ Approach on the global stage whilst extending all practical assistance to the Tibetans. 

This approach represents a bridge between the aspirations of the Tibetan people for self-determination and the geopolitical realities. It is a call for nations to recognise and endorse this pragmatic and non-confrontational stance, encouraging China to engage in dialogue that respects the self-determination of the Tibetan people. This bold political move, championed by His Holiness the 14th Dalai Lama during his political leadership of the Central Tibetan Administration, aims to secure a lasting peaceful resolution to the China-Tibet conflict.

5. Economic Leverage: Ethical Development and Self-Determination

Economic leverage can be harnessed to support the self-determination of the Tibetan people. The UK and other nations sympathetic to Tibet should use their economic influence to encourage responsible business practices in the region. Companies operating in Tibet or with business ties to the region should adhere to ethical, social, and environmental standards.

The economic path forward involves policies that prioritise the economic well-being of Tibetans and support sustainable development. It is a call for nations to explore economic engagements that empower the Tibetan people and contribute to their ability to determine their own political and economic future.

6. International Forums and Self-Determination

International forums provide platforms for advocating self-determination. The UK, the United States, India, and the European Union should consistently raise the Tibetan issue in multilateral organisations. Whether it is the United Nations or other global platforms, such as the G7, these nations must champion the self-determination of the Tibetan people.

Engaging in international forums allows for collective action and the building of alliances. I call for sustained efforts to keep the Tibetan issue on the agenda of these organisations. It is a call for the international community to recognise and respect the right of the Tibetan people to determine their own political future.

Conclusion: A Collective Commitment to Self-Determination

In conclusion, the prospects of Tibet’s future lie in the collective commitment to self-determination, justice, and the preservation of the unique Tibetan identity and culture. The Tibet trajectory involving the United Kingdom and India, is complex, but it presents opportunities for meaningful diplomatic engagement, human rights advocacy, and collaborative efforts on the global stage by making stronger alliances with like-minded countries, including the United States.

Born in a Tibetan refugee camp in Nepal, I stand before you with the conviction that self-determination is not merely a political principle but a fundamental human right. The destiny of Tibet is intertwined with the collective will of the Tibetan people to determine their own political status, economic development, and cultural preservation.

May our shared commitment to justice, human rights, and self-determination be a guiding force in shaping the future of Tibet. Let us stand united in advocating for a future where the Tibetan people can exercise their right to determine their own destiny, free from external coercion or repression. Let us reward the Tibetan people for their continued efforts in pursuit of lasting political resolution through nonviolence and peaceful means for many decades.

Ladies and gentlemen, thank you, and may our collective efforts pave the way for a future where the Tibetan people’s aspirations for self-determination are realised and celebrated on the global stage.

Tsering Passang is the founder and chair of the Global Alliance for Tibet & Persecuted Minorities.